Posted on — 2 Comments

Plans for a second data centre close to South Mimms service station – the third application for a site in Green Belt around Potters Bar

Plans for a second data centre close to South Mimms service station – the third application for a site in Green Belt around Potters Bar

If a change is made to an already agreed planning approval a second large data centre might be built next to the South Mimms service station at junction 23 on the M25 motorway.

This would become the third data centre to be constructed on Green Belt farmland to the south of Potters Bar and to the north of High Barnet.

Yet again the proximity of the M25 and its strategic role as an orbital motorway is eating into the countryside around the edge of north London.

Work has already started – see above – on site clearance and foundations for the construction of a new warehousing and distribution hub at South Mimms in an area known as Charleston Paddocks.

An application has now been made to Hertsmere Borough Council to switch the use of the warehouse from distribution to a data centre.

Since the application for the distribution centre was made in 2023, the government has deemed that data centres are critical national infrastructure opening the way for the possible conversion of what will be a 10,000 square metre warehouse to data processing use.

The Charleston Paddocks site is bounded by the motorway and is immediately to the east of the South Mimms petrol filling station.

It adjoins a much larger site where the US tech firm Equinix has outline approval to build a massive £3.9 billion data centre to be known as the Hertfordshire Campus.

This will be one of the largest in Europe and would almost fill the fields between the South Mimms service station and Dame Alice Owen’s School.

Possible second data centre might be built next to South Mimms Service Station at Junction 23 on M25 motorway -- the third planned in Green Belt farmland south of Potters Bar

Plans for a third data centre close to Potters Bar were unveiled earlier this month.

Plans for a second data centre close to South Mimms service station – the third application for a site in Green Belt around Potters Bar

Orbital Data Centres is proposing to build a £1.5 billion data centre on a 29-acre site south of Junction 24 on farmland between the motorway and The Ridgeway.

As this site straddles the local authority boundary, approval for the Junction 24 centre would require planning approval from both Hertsmere and Enfield Borough Council.

Concern about the impact of applications for data centres in such close proximity has been expressed by Potters Bar Residents Association.

It says the proposal for another data centre beside the massive Equinix Hertfordshire Campus would damage the Green Belt and pose a potential risk to the Mimmshall Brook catchment area.

Approval for a warehouse and distribution centre was only given on the grounds there were “very special circumstances” because it would provide much needed employment and have economic benefits.

A data centre replacing a warehouse would need “substantial additional infrastructure, back-up diesel generation, cooling system, and different water and drainage”.

However, South Mimms and Ridge Parish Council disagrees with the residents’ association and says it would welcome change of use to data centre as it would reduce the number of heavy goods vehicles on narrow roads around the South Mimms service station.

Consultants arguing the case for the data centre say that the sites at South Mimms are within the 20 km zone around the Hemel Hempstead data centre hub and close to the North-East London data centre hub at Waltham Cross.

Unless more data centres are built in the locality there will be a substantial supply deficit by 2030 and therefore removal of the restriction allowing only warehouse and distribution use would align with the government’s objectives on the importance of data centres to the national infrastructure.

The application for change of use has been made by Twenty Planning Ltd on behalf of the owners of the Charleston Paddocks site, Railway Pension Nominees.

Posted on — 1 Comment

Goodbye to (nearly) all this…

Goodbye to (nearly) all this…

Above is the Green Belt north of the M25 with St Albans in the distance. Hertsmere Borough Council proposes to build a new 5,000-home township, Bowmans Cross, on much of this land. It’s just one of many developments close to Barnet in Hertsmere’s draft Local Plan for 2026-41. You have until 17th November to submit your views on the planning application for Bowmans Cross, and until the 19th on the Local Plan.

…And hello to this?

Goodbye to (nearly) all this…

Above: Bowmans Cross looking S-W – visualisation by HTA Design LLP

Hertsmere’s Local Plan

About 79% of the area of Barnet’s northern neighbour, Hertsmere, is currently designated as Metropolitan Green Belt. Five years ago Hertsmere published a draft Local Plan that proposed to build over 10% of it – including a substantial chunk of the pleasant countryside that separates Barnet from Borehamwood and Potters Bar. The Barnet Society and some 20,000 others objected. In January 2022 Hertsmere scrapped that Plan.

Now a new (Regulation 19) Plan is out for consultation, but it’s not very different from the previous version. Its Policy H9.C states,

“Speculative proposals for major-scale housing development upon sites in Hertsmere’s countryside/Green Belt beyond the Borough’s four main towns [Borehamwood, Bushey, Potters Bar & Radlett] will not be positively considered…”

But in practice the Plan pushes the boundaries of Borehamwood and Potters Bar in our direction. These are the new developments that we will notice most:

  • 392 houses south of Borehamwood.
  • Expansion of the Sky studios site north-eastwards from Borehamwood.
  • Three data centres between South Mimms and Potters Bar.
  • 1,292 houses on fields south of Potters Bar.
  • A new employment site south-east of M25 Junction 24.

Development of the fields separating Potters Bar from the M25 will be particularly destructive. Not only do they provide an attractive working agricultural landscape between Potters Bar and Barnet, they link visually with Bentley Heath, Dancers Hill, Wrotham Park and Dyrham Park to create a green panorama much greater than the sum of its parts.

Goodbye to (nearly) all this…

Add to those the new township of Bowmans Cross, and 720 hectares of Green Belt will be lost – an area ten times the size of Hadley Common and Hadley Wood combined.

Another major concern of ours is that little is said about transport improvements, which will be vital to the Plan’s success, especially in Hertsmere’s more rural areas. Barnet already suffers from road and parking congestion due to commuting from Hertfordshire into London, and our bus link with Potters Bar is frail. Building new homes and workplaces near our border seems certain to exacerbate these strains.

It’s also disappointing that although the Plan extols the value of nature and promises green corridors and enhanced pedestrian and cycle routes in towns and new developments, there are no plans for new rural routes of any kind.

We also regret that safeguarding of the cross-border Watling Chase Community Forest is so fleetingly mentioned in the Plan, and its expansion not at all.

Better news for Barnet is that no new building is planned in the countryside south of the M25 and east of the A1. Some of our residents will find work in Hertsmere’s media and IT industries. And new homes near Barnet are likely to be cheaper and more spacious than in Barnet itself. They’ll attract young couples and families who can’t afford property in our borough. It would be ironic if Hertsmere’s new housing ended up benefitting struggling Barnet residents at the expense of its own.

The deadline for representations on the draft Local Plan is 11:59pm on Thursday 19 November.

You can read the relevant documents and guidance here:

You can submit your representation here:

Goodbye to (nearly) all this…

Above: Bowmans Cross looking S-E – visualisation by HTA Design LLP

Bowmans Cross

This will be a new township on open fields and obsolescent sand and gravel quarries by the M25 north of North Mymms. A first phase of 2,500 homes will be built by 2041, growing ultimately to 5,000 homes. Population figures aren’t given, but presumably will eventually total at least 15,000.

There’s clearly something to be said for concentrating new homes in a few places large enough to support a decent range of services such as schools, clinics, retail and social facilities, rather than sprinkling them across our countryside where few services will be viable and residents will depend on cars. A sustainably planned community could also offer great opportunities for recycling and energy generation.

But although the application drawings show lots of greenery, the applicant makes no firm commitment to achieving exemplary environmental standards, only “a holistic view of sustainability, supporting the journey to net zero” (whatever that means). The new homes will only be net zero “where viable” – a big “if”. A site-wide heat network is also “not currently considered to be viable”. A number of further energy efficiency measures “will be considered” but are not guaranteed.

Another fundamental weakness of the scheme is transport. Although Bowmans Cross adjoins the M25, that’s already unacceptably congested at peak times. It has no railway station, nor any plans for a rapid transit system. The application promises new bus services, but the only new route specified at the start of occupation is a shuttle 85 bus to and from Potters Bar station, though eventually this will be replaced by an 86 bus and extended to Hatfield. Four mobility hubs (integrated EV charging, car club, cycle/scooter hire and related facilities) are shown, but in reality most residents seem likely to keep their own cars.

This application looks like a lost opportunity. Last year the government’s New Towns taskforce stated,

“We want exemplary development to be the norm, not the exception. The next generation of new towns must be well-connected, well-designed, sustainable, healthy and attractive places where people want to live and have all the infrastructure, amenities and services necessary to sustain thriving communities established from the outset.” 

Measured against those principles, it is hard to see this planning application as offering much more than a pretty dormitory estate.

The deadline for comments on the Bowmans Cross planning application is 11:59pm on Tuesday 17 November.

You can submit your comments here. The application reference no. is 26/1330/OUTEI.

Posted on — 5 Comments

Fields next to Junction 24 as well as Junction 23 alongside M25 motorway are being proposed as sites for new data centres  

Fields next to Junction 24 as well as Junction 23 alongside M25 motorway are being proposed as sites for new data centres  

Plans are being prepared for a second multi-million-pound data centre to be built north of High Barnet on green belt farmland beside the M25 motorway.

Orbital Data Centres is proposing to spend £1.5 billion constructing and fitting out a 50,000 square foot data centre just south of Junction 24 on a 29-acre site between the motorway and The Ridgeway – see illustration above.

An application by US tech firm Equinix to build a much larger data centre on an 85-acre site to the north of Junction 23 is already in the early stages of consideration by Hertsmere Borough Council.

The Junction 23 centre, which would cost £3.9 billion, would almost fill the fields between South Mimms service station and Dame Alice Owen’s School at Potters Bar.

Plans for a second data centre alongside M25 motorway close to junction 24. Plans already in for a data close to junction 23

The proposed Junction 24 centre, to the south of Potters Bar, would be the first to be built by Orbital Data Centres.

Approval would be needed from both Hertsmere and Enfield Borough Council as the site straddles the boundary between the two authorities.

Orbital purchased the site, described as dis-used farmland, from Enfield Council earlier this year.

After public consultation on the plan during November, the company hopes to submit its planning application before the end of the year with construction due to be completed by 2030 when the centre is scheduled to be supplied with its own electricity grid connection and substation.

At a public presentation of the plan, Orbital said the new centre would not draw from the local electricity network, and it would be cooled with a closed-loop system which would circulate the same water and not draw on the local mains supply.

Over half the 29-acre site would remain as open space with wooded, wetland and grassland around the data centre with the addition of 640 new trees. Five acres would be open to the public with footpaths through the site.

Preparation of the site and construction of the two data centre buildings would provide 1,400 to 1,700 jobs during the three years of construction.

Once in operation, the centre would provide 170 jobs with around 85 more in the wider area.

Orbital calculate the new centre would provide a £30 million a year boost to the local economy. This would include £6.8 million in business rates of which £2.7 million a year could be kept for local services.

Orbital’s planning consultants acknowledged that having to seek planning permission from two separate authorities was a complication.

The western half of the site is within Hertsmere. Although previously green belt, the site is now regarded as grey belt and has been designated for employment use, which includes data centres.

However, there is a dispute about the status of the eastern half of the site within Enfield.

Under the Enfield local plan, it was originally designated for employment use, but a planning inspector subsequently proposed that designation should be removed as it would result “in a very high degree of harm” to green belt land around Junction 24.

In the view of Orbital’s consultants, the subsequent declaration by the government that data centres should be considered critical national infrastructure would now have to be taken into consideration, along with the new procedure for redesignating green belt as grey belt.

Outline planning permission for the much larger data centre near Junction 23 – to be known as the Hertfordshire Campus – was granted in 2025 and Equinix is now involved in detailed discussions with Hertsmere over the infrastructure which be required.

Public consultation on the Junction 24 centre closes on 22 November.

 For more details of the two proposed schemes:

Posted on — Leave a comment

Mayor of London’s target for 7,000 homes on Barnet green belt highlights significance of land bank at Arkley valued at £150 million

Mayor of London’s target for 7,000 homes on Barnet green belt highlights significance of land bank at Arkley valued at £150 million

A large expanse of green belt woodland and fields at Arkley – which is being held as a multi-million-pound landbank for possible future housing – is attracting heightened interest from developers.

Contractors have painted blue marks on a long line of trees in one 25-acre plot. Another 38-acre plot has a 24-hour security patrol to prevent unauthorised entry.

These plots are part of a 148-acre triangular wedge of woodland and fields to the north of Barnet Road (between The Gate public house at Arkley and Stirling Corner roundabout) and which are bounded by Rowley Lane to the east and the A1 Barnet by-pass to the west.

Mayor of London’s target for 7,000 homes on Barnet green belt highlights significance of land bank at Arkley valued at £150 million

Online research suggests the area has space for 1,200 homes. If planning permission was approved, the plots have a potential combined value of £150 million.

This is one of the areas suggested for development in the recently published Draft London Plan.

Barnet Council has been told by the Mayor of London that up to 7,000 homes might have to be built on green belt land within the borough.

There seems a high probability that some of the woods and fields in and around Arkley might have to be sacrificed if the target is to be met.

Two other green belt sites, which are both off Rowley Lane and which could be re-designated as grey belt, are already the subject of planning applications.

Mayor of London’s target for 7,000 homes on Barnet green belt highlights significance of land bank at Arkley valued at £150 million

Nearby residents and dog walkers recently saw contractors painting blue marks on a long line of trees in the 25-acre plot to the north of Barnet Road.

They believe these marks might possibly be plot boundaries, and together with the installation of new fences, indicate heightened interest on the part of developers.

This 25-acre site is listed online as being owned by Hallway Properties Ltd, a subsidiary of the William Pears real estate and investment group.

It is said to have the potential for 192 homes and an estimated value of £39 million with planning permission.

Mayor of London’s target for 7,000 homes on Barnet green belt highlights significance of land bank at Arkley valued at £150 million

Another plot of 38 acres closer to the Stirling Corner roundabout includes the cleared site of a former Metropolitan Police sports ground and pavilion.

Mayor of London’s target for 7,000 homes on Barnet green belt highlights significance of land bank at Arkley valued at £150 million

There are warning signs at the two gated entrances. A security patrol provides protection because of fears the land could be accessed by travellers’ caravans or be used for unauthorised raves.

With space for 285 homes, this site could be worth £43 million. It is listed as being owned by Modular Builders Ltd, thought to be part of a property group.

An online search indicates that another 48-acre site closer to the Rowley Lane roundabout, which is listed under the ownership of the Maccabi Recreation Trust, has space for 365 homes and could be worth £56 million.

Mayor of London’s target for 7,000 homes on Barnet green belt highlights significance of land bank at Arkley valued at £150 million

The two requests for planning permission for plots within this triangle of land include an application from Bugler Homes of Rickmansworth to discuss plans for 230 homes and an 80-bed care home on the 17-acre site of a former pig farm off Rowley Lane.

Closer to the junction of Rowley Lane with Barnet Road, an application has been made to the council to construct a site for 12 pitches for travellers’ caravans on a one-acre plot behind Rowley Lodge.

Within the last two years most of the 38-acre site closest to Stirling Corner roundabout, which was purchased by Modular Builders Ltd in 1986, has been cleared of derelict buildings which were once part of the former Metropolitan Police sports ground.

Originally known as the Finsbury War Memorial Playing Field, the sports ground was opened by the Duke of Edinburgh in 1955 in commemoration of those who lost their lives in World War II.

It included football pitches and a running track and was taken over by the Metropolitan Police which later sold the site.

The abandoned pavilion became a magnate for graffiti artists, urban explorers and party goers. One unauthorised rave in 2014 was said to have attracted over 500 people.

Mayor of London’s target for 7,000 homes on Barnet green belt highlights significance of land bank at Arkley valued at £150 million

Some graffiti is still visible but since most of the buildings were demolished the whole area has become heavily overgrown.

When Barnet Football Club was first considering a move from Underhill, the site was suggested as being the ideal location for a new stadium, but the owners were unwilling to consider selling the land.

The Mayor of London has proposed a ten-year target for Barnet to build 32,000 new houses including 7,000 on green belt land within the borough.

In its response to the Draft London Plan, the council says any release of protected land should only take place if there is “comprehensive master planning” for the area.

This would require significant infrastructure investment, environmental enhancement and a clear demonstration that the development could be accommodated and was sustainable.

The council stresses that any review of Barnet’s green belt should be considered alongside proposals for a possible Barnet Regional Park taking in woodland and fields in Arkley and Mill Hill.

When the plan was discussed at the recent annual meeting of Barnet Residents’ Association, there was a recognition that the loss of some of Arkley’s green belt was probably inevitable.

London Draft Plan which proposes building 7,000 homes on Barnet green belt puts spotlight on developers' landbank at Arkley said to be worth £150 million,.

 Councillor Richard Barnes (Barnet Vale), who is chair of Barnet Council’s planning committee, acknowledged that housing development was likely in the green belt along Rowley Lane, Arkley Lane, and Galley Lane, and also on land to the north and south of the Stirling Corner roundabout.

These sites were listed in a 400-page London green belt assessment which was published alongside the draft London plan – a plan that was out for consultation and which he thought would take at least two years to implement.

Gordon Massey, who leads for the residents’ association on planning, warned of the consequences that lay ahead if there was extensive redevelopment in Arkley, especially in view of the London plan’s acceptance of the need for blocks of flats as high as nine storeys.

He thought there were as many as four sites in Arkley which were vulnerable, posing the threat that tower blocks could be built there.

“I hope you are wrong,” replied Councillor Barnes. “We would not support tower blocks in Arkley. Green belt at the edge of the borough needs to be protected and I have not heard of any plans to develop that land.”

Posted on — Leave a comment

Residents in High Barnet neighbourhood concerned about plans for large new sports hall at Queen Elizabeth’s School

Residents in High Barnet neighbourhood concerned about plans for large new sports hall at Queen Elizabeth’s School

Some residents in roads around Queen Elizabeth’s Boys School have registered objections with Barnet Council over an application to construct a new multi-use sports hall.

They fear the four-storey building will dominate the area and generate added traffic congestion.

Sports groups and other community organisations would be able to hire the new facilities during evenings, weekends and school holidays, as is already the case with QE’s swimming pool and recital hall.

Above changing rooms on the ground floor of the new building, there would be a high ceiling sports hall with layouts for basketball, five-a-side football, badminton and table tennis and on the top floor ten new classrooms.

Outside there would be six cricket practice nets and six Eton fives courts with a tiered seating area for 64 spectators.

Residents in High Barnet neighbourhood concerned about plans for large new sports hall at Queen Elizabeth’s School

Many of the objections registered so far with the council are from residents of Regina Close – see above – which is next to the main Queens Road entrance to the school.

They say the construction of a mega sports hall so close to their homes would be incongruous and out of character, as it would be two storeys higher than other buildings on the school site.

Residents in High Barnet neighbourhood concerned about plans for large new sports hall at Queen Elizabeth’s School

Classrooms on the top floor would have a direct line of sight into the bedrooms of the Regina Close houses.

An overriding objection of residents in Regina Close, Queens Road and Granville Road is their fear that developing a sports hall, open seven days a week, all year round, would exacerbate the already “terrible” traffic congestion around the school.

Yet another attraction in out-of-school hours would only compound what they say is the failure of QE’s administrative staff to tackle uncontrolled parking by parents and traffic jams caused by the arrival and departure of a dozen or more coaches and mini-buses taking pupils to destinations across north and west London.  

Disturbance to the neighbourhood continues outside the school week as the swimming pool is hired out at weekends despite a claim by residents that the original planning conditions ruled out use on Sundays.

Objections registered by residents of Byng Road, which adjoins the school’s northern playing field, say they oppose the felling of five established oaks which are the subject of tree protection orders.

Currently a line of oaks forms the northern boundary of the school site, and objectors say that a continuous border of established trees would be lost to make way for the Eton five courts and other facilities.

Queen Elizabeth's Boys' School plan for large new sports hall prompts objections from residents of surrounding roads

A single-storey former music block next to the swimming pool – see above – would be demolished to make way for the new sports hall.

When the plans were displayed at a public presentation, planning consultants insisted the new sports hall was being provided within what was already a “tight campus” which explained why the school had to intensify the use of existing buildings and the areas which could be redeveloped.

QE Boys – as it is still known locally – is a state-funded grammar school for boys with an annual intake of 192 pupils, a figure which the school says will remain unchanged.

 Fund raising will start next year if permission is obtained for what the school says is part of a continuing programme to upgrade facilities within its existing site.

Applications will be made for government financial support and sports grants and an appeal launched among ex-pupils. The aim would be to start construction in 2028 and complete the work in 2029.

For full details of QE’s application see Barnet Council planning application 26/3400/FUL. Closing date for comment Thursday 5 November.

Posted on — 6 Comments

Deadline looms to comment on planning application for ‘protected’ site in Arkley

The Orchard, Rowley Lodge Field, Arkley: views before, of unspoilt nature, and after, of illegally felled trees

The land in Arkley’s Green Belt illustrated above is a Site of Borough Importance for Nature Conservation and a Tree Preservation Zone, and until unlawfully cleared of trees last February was a pretty place to walk. A planning application has since been submitted for 12 travellers caravan pitches on it. You have until Thursday 29 October to submit your comments on the application.

In April, Nick Jones wrote here about the horrendous destruction. Barnet planners referred it to the Forestry Commission, which has confirmed that the felling was a breach of the Forestry Act 1967. We’ve been informed, however, that the Forestry Commission has decided not to take legal action. Barnet Council is now consulting its own legal advisors.

Deadline looms to comment on planning application for ‘protected’ site in Arkley

These events conform to a pattern of erosion of the Green Belt in and around Arkley that has caused the Barnet Society increasing concern. I first reported on the threats in a web post in 2020, and Nick Jones wrote about land sales in Arkley in a web post in 2023.

Barnet Council’s 2025 Local Plan contains good policies to protect its Green Belt and an imaginative commitment to designate an arc of greenery from Mill Hill & Scratchwood to Arkley & Hadley as a Regional Park – not unlike the Lee Valley Regional Park – which in theory should provide extra protection.

But successive governments have relaxed planning restrictions, and (as described in my August web post on the draft London Plan) the Mayor of London wants Barnet to build 7,000 new homes in its Green Belt.

The Barnet Society isn’t opposed in principle to new homes in the Green Belt – whether for travellers or static residents – but accepts them only as a last resort, only when the buildings and their surroundings are in sustainable locations, and only when designed to the highest environmental standards.

The present application is none of those things. If approved, it would reward illegal behaviour and set a deeply worrying precedent for the remaining greenery between Arkley and Borehamwood.

Deadline looms to comment on planning application for ‘protected’ site in Arkley

You can see the application documents and plans here. Search for 26/3182/FUL. They aren’t a long read!

The Barnet Society strongly objects to the application. We’ve drafted the following comments:

  1. It is contrary to National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF) policies S5 (development outside settlements), GB6 (development in the Green Belt) & HO7 (need for homes).

2. The land strongly contributes to these Green Belt purposes in NPPF policy GB2:

(a) Checking unrestricted sprawl of large built‑up areas;

(b) Preventing neighbouring towns from merging;

(d) Preserving the setting and special character of historic towns.

3. The Design & Access Statement’s assertion that the site should be classified as Grey Belt is absurd. It is part of Rowley Lodge Field, 4.4 hectares of trees and meadow, a Grade II Site of Borough Importance for Nature Conservation and a Tree Preservation Zone. Its unlawful clearance in February is an extreme case of degrading Green Belt land before an application claiming Grey Belt status. Such cynical practice is unacceptable as a route to planning approval.

4. The applicant’s claim that the Mayor of London’s Gypsy and Traveller Accommodation Needs Assessment 2025 proves a need for 16 travellers pitches in Barnet is correct, but fails to address the basic inappropriateness of this particular site. The precedent of the Planning Inspectorate’s over-ruling of Barnet’s refusal of an application for pitches in Mays Lane (23/3816/FUL) is irrelevant because that decision was conditional on sole use by named travellers and their dependents.

5. The proposal contravenes Barnet Council policy HOU06 (Travellers et al), conditions A-E.

6. The proposal is fundamentally unsustainable. The site’s biodiversity would be reduced. No environmental improvements are proposed. Vehicle and pedestrian access is hazardous. Site utilities are nil. There are no local nurseries, schools, shops or medical services. Public transport connections are poor. Unavoidable vehicle usage would exacerbate existing congestion on local roads.

The unauthorised destruction of natural habitat is compounded by a perfunctory planning application that lacks the detail essential for such a sensitive location. This site is part of a vital – but already thin – tract of greenery separating Arkley from Borehamwood and South Mimms. Proposals for other housing developments on neighbouring plots include 300 new homes on Arkley Manor Farm. Further erosion of the Green Belt is unacceptable and must be refused.

Submit your own comments

Arkley residents have distributed the flyer below, helpfully telling you how to do so.

Deadline looms to comment on planning application for ‘protected’ site in Arkley
Deadline looms to comment on planning application for ‘protected’ site in Arkley
Posted on — Leave a comment

Underhill village residents face intense competition in Barnet Council bidding process to buy back former youth club for local community

Underhill village residents face intense competition in Barnet Council bidding process to buy back former youth club for local community

As Barnet Council starts to consider numerous bids to buy the derelict former Quinta Youth Club in Mays Lane, the residents’ association for the neighbourhood has appealed for the building to be returned to community use rather than go to the highest bidder.

Quinta Village Green Residents’ Association has submitted what it says is a “comprehensive competitive bid” for the building on which the council has placed a £300,000 valuation.

Association chair Gina Theodorou says she hopes the council will finally agree to return to Mays Lane residents a clubhouse which was built by the community in the 1960s and which been derelict for the last 20 years.

Plans have been prepared with pledges of financial support to use the site to build a combined community hub, cafe and youth centre.

With the expiry of a six-month pause allowing community groups to prepare their bids after the clubhouse was designated an asset of community value, the sale process was opened to public bids.

Council officials are understood to have been surprised by the number of commercial as well as community offers for the property.

There are said to have been as many of 40 expressions of interest.

In acknowledging they are up against competitive offers, Gina Theodorou, chair of the residents’ association, said they recognise the council must assess the bids through its formal disposal process.

“But we hope the council will give full consideration to the lasting social and community value that our proposal could deliver, alongside the financial offer.

“Residents have already done an extraordinary amount to demonstrate what a community hub could become.

“We now hope the council will give this community-led proposal the opportunity it deserves.”

Quinta Village Green Residents hoping strong bid for new community hub will help beat off higher bid for delelict former Quinta Youth Club in Mays Lane.

Initially the Quinta Project, a newly incorporated company, is proposing a fully-functioning single storey building, designed to allow for possible future expansion, should funding and community needs justify it – see artist’s impression above.

A new, accessible community hub would offer youth activities, sport, music and creative opportunities, a community café, and affordable space for local charities and community groups.

A consultation conducted by the association attracted over 440 responses, of which 97 per cent were in favour of the building being returned to community use and 78 per cent identifying provision for young people one of the area’s most underserved needs.

Pupils at Totteridge Academy and Underhill School had been consulted and one of their clearest messages was that young people wanted somewhere welcoming and affordable to meet friends and engage in organised activities.

The derelict building sits alongside Quinta Village Green, which is a legally protected open space. A new community hub would be able to connect with outdoor sport and recreation.

In preparing their submission, for which there is said to be significant financial backing from the Hadley Trust, the association commissioned extensive feasibility work and prepared detailed five-year operating forecasts.

The Quinta Club was conceived in the 1960s when the local community drew up plans for a youth centre for what was then the Whitings Hill estate in view of a “dearth of opportunity” for young people in Underhill.

The foundation stone was laid in July 1965, and the club was built with the help of local volunteers and tradespeople.

Ms Theodorou believed there is a chance to recreate that sense of community.

“We want to bring that spirit back, creating somewhere young people can feel safe, make friends and develop their interests, while offering a welcoming place for residents of every generation.

“More than 60 years later, Barnet’s own youth strategy needs analysis reaches the same conclusion about this part of the borough.

“After two decades of closure and decay, residents now hope to restore the club’s original purpose for a new generation.”

Posted on — 1 Comment

Fiery exchanges as Labour and Conservative councillors clash over accuracy of list of green belt sites for housing around High Barnet

Barnet's Labour and Conservative councillors clash over accuracy of a list of green belt sites which could be designated for new housing around High Barnet

Concern about threats to the green belt and the loss of popular open spaces dominated a question-and-answer session held at the annual meeting of Barnet Residents Association.

Councillor Richard Barnes (Barnet Vale), who is chair of Barnet Council’s planning committee  – see above with association co-chair Ken Rowland (left) and Emma Morgan, membership secretary  –  set out the options following publication of a draft plan for London which is proposing the construction of up to 7,000 new homes on green belt land within the borough.

He ended up getting caught in crossfire between Labour and Conservatives councillors as they argued about the authenticity of a list of sites – including playing fields, golf courses and cemeteries – which could be redesignated as grey belt with potential for redevelopment for housing.

The list emerged earlier this month with Labour councillors accusing their opponents of political scaremongering whereas Conservative councillors hit back accusing the Labour-controlled council of not coming clean with residents about the potential loss of precious amenity land and much-appreciated green spaces.

The controversial list – the wording of which Councillor Barnes insisted was “misleading and inaccurate” – includes sites such as Ark Pioneer Academy playing fields, King George V playing fields, Quinta Open Space, Hendon and Finchley golf courses, cemetery land at Edgwarebury and Hendon, land north of Totteridge Common Road and Hadley Common Road.

Councillors Barnes said these sites and others were listed as being “suitable for grey belt designation” but this wording did not exist in any official document.

“This description is inaccurate and perhaps deliberately so for political effect. The list includes sites like cemeteries and playing fields which are never going to be redeveloped.”

But he did acknowledge that the sites were listed in a 400-page London green belt assessment which was published alongside the draft London plan – a plan that was out for consultation and which he thought would take at least two years to implement.

He was supported at the meeting by Councillor Emma Whysall (High Barnet, Labour) who deplored the scaremongering taking place on social media.

An important point of the whole exercise was that some green belt land might be downgraded to grey belt while other sites might be upgraded to merit full green belt protection.

She maintained that many of the sites which had been listed were more than likely to be included in the council’s plans for a possible regional park which could be created to include green belt land around Arkley and Mill Hill.

She and Councillor Barnes were challenged by Councillor James Esses (High Barnet, Conservative) who insisted the list was part of formal document published alongside the draft London plan.

He thought it was wrong to suggest the list was “not official” when it was in the current plan. As it was unlikely the London plan would be revised, the Conservatives had voted against it.

Councillor David Longstaff (Barnet Vale, Conservative) said that Labour councillors were in no position to challenge the wording of the London plan which was clear that 7,000 houses would have to be built on green belt land within the borough.

The ten-year target set by the Mayor of London was for Barnet to build 32,000 new houses – a target which Councillor Longstaff predicted would see an increase in the borough’s population of 310,000 ten years ago to 430,000 in ten years’ time.

“If people don’t start objecting now in a big way, this plan will be steamrollered through, and an awful lot of the new homes will be one- and two-bedroom flats instead of family homes.”

Councillor Barnes agreed that housing development was likely on some of what is now designated as green belt, such as land in Arkley along Rowley Lane, Arkley Lane, and Galley Lane, and land north and south of the Stirling Corner roundabout.

Gordon Massey, who leads for the residents’ association on planning, warned of the consequences that lay ahead if there was extensive redevelopment in Arkley, especially in view of the London plan acceptance of the need for blocks of flats as high as nine storeys.

He thought there were as many as four sites in Arkley which were vulnerable, posing the threat that tower block could be built there.

“I hope you are wrong,” replied Councillor Barnes. “We would not support tower blocks in Arkley. Green belt at the edge of the borough needs to be protected and I have not heard of any plans to develop that land.”

Earlier Mr Massey criticised the failure of the Deputy Mayor of London to publish his reasons for overturning Barnet Council’s rejection of a Transport for London plan to build high-rise flats on the car park at High Barnet tube station.

He thought the failure to release the official notification – which could trigger a possible legal challenge – was down to the developers getting “cold feet.”

Major housebuilders were pulling out of Greater London schemes because the Mayor of London’s targets for the construction of affordable homes made these schemes unviable.

One high point of the meeting was news from several members that residents of Sunset View and Hadley Grove have been successful in their bid at an auction to buy half of a one-acre copse alongside Christchurch Lane.

A plan to build a large house on the site was rejected by Barnet Council and the residents made a joint bid to purchase half the site to ensure it remained protected woodland.

In view an offer from the Woodland Trust to maintain the small deciduous wood, the residents are hoping that Barnet Council, which owns the other half acre, might release it to the Woodland Trust.

The meeting was told that formal consultations are about to start on establishing a 20mph zone in streets in and around Alston Road and Stapylton Road.

Councillor Whysall said the plan was to create a safer zone in the streets in an area bounded to the north and west of Wood Street, High Street Road and St Albans Road.  

Posted on — Leave a comment

With a rapidly approaching deadline for bids, Quinta Village Green residents step up their campaign to take over derelict youth club

With a rapidly approaching deadline for bids, Quinta Village Green residents step up their campaign to take over derelict youth club

A packed meeting at Underhill gave enthusiastic support to a community bid to purchase the derelict former Quinta Youth Club in Mays Lane which is being sold off by Barnet Council.

Fears that the building might go to the highest bidder because of the council’s dire financial position led to a last-minute appeal to local residents to demonstrate the strength of their campaign to secure a new combined community hub and youth centre.

Gina Theodorou, chair of the Quinta Village Green Residents Association, made a passionate plea to the neighbourhood to demonstrate to councillors why the council should respect the wishes of those who lived in Underhill.

Provision of services and support for young people was lower in the Underhill area than in the rest of the Borough of Barnet and the meeting was adamant the former youth club, which the community built in the mid-1960s, should be returned and redeveloped for their benefit.

With a rapidly approaching deadline for bids, Quinta Village Green residents step up their campaign to take over derelict youth club

Leaders and representatives of other groups and organisations from in and around High Barnet lined up to give their backing to what they agreed was a well resourced and imaginative bid to buy back a building on which the council has placed a £300,000 valuation.

“Of course, there are other bidders, and we know there is a major risk that another group or organisation might try to outbid us, but Barnet Council should realise this is the preferred scheme of those who live in Underhill,” said Ms Theodorou.

Quinta Village Green Residents Association has campaigned long and hard for the restoration or replacement of the former youth club and secured a six-month pause in the sale of the building after they succeeded in persuading the council to declare it an asset of community value.

With a rapidly approaching deadline for bids, Quinta Village Green residents step up their campaign to take over derelict youth club

Plans and artists’ impressions of the proposed community hub were presented to the meeting by architect Simon Kaufman – with the help of his daughter Ana.

With a rapidly approaching deadline for bids, Quinta Village Green residents step up their campaign to take over derelict youth club

A preferred option was for the new hub to have a central corridor with a sports hall on one side and activity rooms on the other with a new community café looking out on to Quinta Village Green.

All the rooms would have sliding walls offering flexible space for different activities together with plenty of storage space.

A single storey building was proposed but if there was sufficient funding there could be an upper floor.

Full advantage would be taken of their site in the Green Belt with community gardens and perhaps an orchard alongside the building.

Along the Mays Lane frontage there would be 19 parking spaces, including accessible spaces for wheelchairs, plus 40 cycle spaces as the new hub could become a stopping off point for cyclists along the Dollis Valley green walk.

Ms Theodorou stressed the importance of residents expressing their support before the deadline for bids on 23 October – even the smallest donation would help https://gofund.me/70e0fe9c2 as would responses to their community survey https://forms.gle/Ynmib6DYGKxCTcoD7

Two charities – Hadley Trust and Common Nature – have told the residents association that financial assistance might well be available towards the purchase and reconstruction if the local community unites around the plan and succeeds with its bid.

Quinta Village Green residents step up campaign to take over derelict yourh club as deadline approaches for bids to Barnet Council

Among those attending the meeting – see above, from left to right – were Underhill Councillor Josh Tapper, Chipping Barnet MP Dan Tomlinson, Gina Theodorou, and Julian Desborough, trustee of the Hope Corner Community Centre which was re-opened as part of the Dollis Valley regeneration.

Mr Desborough said the 12,500 residents of the Underhill ward were in desperate need of more community space and services for young people. What was so important about the Quinta project was that, unlike Hope Corner, it was in the middle of an open space in the Green Belt.

His plea for more services and activities for Underhill’s youngsters was reinforced by Amber Jones of the Young Barnet Foundation.

Out of 223 organisations offering services for young people across the borough, there were less than 20 in the north of the area and only four in Underhill.

Andy Rimmer, vicar of Christ Church, Barnet, added his support for Ms Theodorou’s argument that Underhill was in desperate need of a safe space for young people and a centre offering warm surroundings for the elderly in winter.

Among those to be canvassed later this month for ideas for a youth centre will be students at Totteridge Academy – an initiative welcomed by Eve Rogers, managing director of Grow, the academy’s school farm.

After the meeting, both the Chipping Barnet MP and Underhill councillor, stressed the importance of the council considering all the bids free of political interference.

Dan Tomlinson said that nonetheless he hoped the council would “consider very carefully the strength” of the Quinta community bid.

“We have to bring the derelict youth club back into use and bring it back in a way which serves the local community.  There is a massive need for space which helps provide activities for young people.”

Josh Tapper insisted that as a Barnet councillor he could not take a position and had to remain neutral during the bidding process, but he had been anxious to attend the meeting and listen to the case being put forward by the community.   

Posted on — 4 Comments

Conversion of Barnet Post Office into flats means now more homes than shops in High Street

Conversion of Barnet Post Office into flats means now more homes than shops in High Street

High Barnet’s former Crown Post Office is to be converted into nine self-contained flats if an application is approved by Barnet Council – a change of use which highlights the rapidly changing nature of the High Street.

Consultants for the owners say conversion of its interior and former sorting office into nine one- and two-bedroom flats will have “no impact” on the significance of what is a locally listed building in the Wood Street Conservation Area.   

Over recent years vacant space above retail and commercial premises within the town centre has increasingly been converted for residential use.

High Barnet’s High Street now has more homes than shops.

Registration of residential addresses for postal deliveries reveals the scale of a dramatic increase: currently there are a total of 398 residential addresses listed along the High Street, up from around 50 ten years ago.

Longer than many high streets at 0.7 kilometres, it extends from the junction with Meadway and the upper entrance to High Barnet tube station, through the town centre, passed the parish church and The Spires shopping centre and on to Hadley Green.

Most of these homes are flats above retail premises with front door entrances either onto the High Street or at the rear.

The application to convert the Post Office into flats is just one of several conversions and new builds which are currently underway or are about to start.

By far the largest recent development in the High Street was the new Lightfield estate of houses and flats on the site the site of the former Brake Shear House complex of offices and workshops.

But it is the continuing conversion of vacant space above shops and offices which is dramatically increasing the number of people who now live along the High Street – driving the number to levels not seen since before World War II.

Post war expansion of nationally owned retail and business chains led to a dramatic fall in the number of individual shopkeepers and traders who used to live “above the shop”.

This has resulted in much of the accommodation on the upper floors having remained vacant for decades – a trend which is now being rapidly reversed.

Conversion of Barnet Post Office into flats means now more homes than shops in High Street

Opposite the Post Office, approval has been obtained for the construction of a new four-storey building with 11 new homes on the site of the former Foxtons estate agency at the corner of the High Street and Moxon Street.

Conversion of Barnet Post Office into flats means now more homes than shops in High Street

New retail premises with “luxury apartments” above have recently been constructed in the High Street in vacant shop premises opposite Queen Elizabeth’s Girls’ School.

A few doors further up the High Street, the former Barnet Court House was converted into flats some years ago.

Conversion of Barnet Post Office into flats means now more homes than shops in High Street

Three one-bedroom apartments “with terraces and views towards the city” are on offer following a conversion nearing completion in a former High Street health store between Rymans and Boots.

However, an application to convert the upper floors of Hadley House – formerly The King George public house – was recently withdrawn.

Robin Bishop, the Barnet Society’s lead on planning and the environment, comments, “The Society has long supported converting unused upper floors in the High Street into homes. We also welcome sensitive roof and rear extensions, provided that they respect the character of the Wood Street and Monken Hadley Conservation Areas. But it’s disappointing that many developers prioritise profit over adding to our historic town centre’s attractive architectural heritage.”

Conversion of Barnet Post Office into flats means now more homes than shops in High Street

Planning consultants say the former post office, which is sited on a “gentle curve” of the High Street, is “a fine example of Edwardian commercial architecture designed in the Near-Jacobean Revival style”.

It was constructed between 1903 and 1905 to the designs of Jasper Wagner for the Office of Works and by 1925 offered a wide range of functions as an important postal facility– “head post, telegraph, telephone, money order, savings bank, insurance, annuity and parcel post office”.

Noted for its ornate Edwardian architecture, notable features include detailed stonework, a stone carving of the coat of arms, and additional stonework above the top floor windows with the initials ER – the motif of King Edward VII.

Conversion of Barnet Post Office into flats means now more homes than shops in High Street

An historic carriageway to the side of the post office reveals ancillary buildings at the rear including the former sorting office.

Architects Alan Cox Associates say the application, made under permitted development rights, is to convert the premises into four one-person studio flats; four two-person one-bedroom flats; and one two-person one-bedroom duplex flat.

There would be a 12-space cycle park at the rear but no car parking space. The applicant states there would be an agreement with Barnet Council that no parking permits could be obtained.

An independent commercial unit, facing on to the High Street, would be remain.

Under a permitted development rights application there can be no changes to the exterior of the existing buildings, so the architects say there will be “no change” to the aesthetic of the building.

“The proposed internal alterations are discreet and will be virtually imperceptible from the public realm.

“Accordingly, the proposals will sustain the heritage significance of the site and its positive contribution to the surrounding historic environment, without resulting in harm to any heritage assets.”

At present, included in the frontage, is an integrated red-letter box which has remained in use since the closure of the crown post office last year when it became a franchised post office with premises on the other side of the High Street, managed by the UOE store group.  

Barnet’s crown post office had a distinguished history, originally having been a regular stopping off point for mail coaches heading out of London for Scotland and the north.

Until the 1930s Barnet was one of the best-known coaching towns on the outskirts of London.

When the mail coach for Scotland left St Martins-le-Grand one of the first stops on the Great North Road was Barnet post office where it picked up mail.

Application to convert Barnet Post Office into nine self contained flats which will increase stlll further number of people living in a High Street with more homes than shops

Set in the wall, just above the pavement, between the front door and the letter box, is one of the original boundary stones of the ancient parish of Chipping Barnet – which is regularly pointed out during the annual ceremony to mark the Beating of the Bounds of the parish of Barnet.

Posted on — 1 Comment

Concern over added pressure which new housing developments in Barnet area will place on already busy GP surgeries

Concern over added pressure which new housing developments in Barnet area will place on already busy GP surgeries

New housing developments around High Barnet and New Barnet are likely to lead to an increase of well over 2,000 in the local population but residents’ groups say there is no sign of health authorities delivering on promises to boost capacity at already over-stretched doctors’ surgeries.

Of the five GP practices within a two-kilometre radius, three already have fewer doctors than recommended by the British Medical Association.

Long-standing Save New Barnet campaigner, John Dix –above – says assurances given by developers when recent planning applications were approved have turned out to be misleading and so far, have not been honoured.

Despite the absence of any plans to expand GP practices, developers are continuing to claim that these five local surgeries are accepting new patients indicating that there is “some spare capacity in the local area”.

Concern over added pressure which new housing developments in Barnet area will place on already busy GP surgeries

Mr Dix told the Barnet Society that these assurances are not supported by the latest Barnet-area statistics from the General Practice Workforce for the ratio of patients per doctor.

A failure to get meaningful replies from the integrated care board for north Lonon highlighted what he believes is the failure of the health authorities to address the extra demand being placed on doctors’ surgeries by the scale of housing redevelopment underway in High Banet and New Barnet.   

When permission was given for nearly 500 new flats which are being built on the site of New Barnet’s former gas works, local residents were led to believe that there were proposals to merge three nearby doctors’ surgeries to create a combined practice to be housed at the East Barnet Health Centre.

Concern over the extra demand which will be placed on doctors' surgeries in High Barnet and New Barnet as a result of  new housing developments adding over 2,000 to local population.

To his consternation Mr Dix has discovered that the original proposal to increase the number of doctors and enlarge East Barnet Health Centre – at an estimated cost of £1.4 million – appears to have been shelved.

He has now been told by the integrated care board that it disputes whether there was ever a proposal to merge The Addington and The Village surgeries with the practice at the East Barnet Health Centre.

“Apparently the developers Fairview did offer some of the retail space in the Park Quarter development for a new GP surgery, but this was considered unsuitable and the board said it did not get the money it needed to enlarge the East Barnet Health Centre.

“So, the net outcome is that we are going to have 486 new flats at Park Quarter   and no additional GP services for 1,000-plus new residents.”

Mr Dix said the GP shortfall had been acknowledged by Berkeley Homes when it obtained planning approval for 80 new homes next to Park Quarter on the site of the former gasometer.

“Berkeley Homes’ consultants recommended that Barnet Council should undertake measures to increase GP capacity through the use of community infrastructure levy money, but again there is no sign that any action is being taken.”

The GP shortfall in New Barnet is likely to be mirrored in High Barnet where major housing developments could add nearly 600 new homes – 145 in Moxon Street; 115 at Whalebones in Wood Street; and 328 at High Barnet tube station.

There is still the possibility of a High Court challenge to the decision by the Deputy Mayor of London to approve the construction of five blocks of flats on the station car park and adjoining land, but Mr Dix says consultants for Transport for London relied on the same assurances given by other developers.

A consultants’ report for TfL’s subsidiary, Places for London, said there were “five GP surgeries within 2 kilometres of the site, all of which are accepting new patients”, and that any increase in demand could be offset through financial contributions from Barnet Council’s income from the community infrastructure levy.

Mr Dix believes the failure of the integrated care board and Barnet Council to address the local GP shortfall results from their concentration of resources into the provision of primary care facilities for major housing developments at Brent Cross and Colindale.

“Unfortunately, the health authorities and the council are failing to look at the bigger picture and recognise that all the infill developments around High Barnet and New Barnet are having a significant cumulative impact on already over-stretched GP services.

“To be fair, the integrated care board insists it continues to keep local primary care capacity under review and remains interested in exploring future opportunities to expand services at East Board Health Centre should funding become available.

“The new draft London Plan says we need to build 32,730 new homes in Barnet so there is real concern that the health infrastructure, including hospital beds, will not be in place to meet the demand.”

General Practice Workforce statistics published in June indicate the strain current demand is placing on GP services at the five surgeries which the developers have referred to in their planning applications:

(The British Medical Association recommendation is 1 full-time equivalent qualified GP per 1,800 patients.)

The Old Court House Surgery, Wood Street – 10,239 patients; 5.2 full-time equivalent qualified doctors; 4.2 qualified doctors; ratio of patients to qualified GP, 2,420.  

Longrove Surgery, Vale Drive Primary Care Centre – 17,186 patients; 11.5 full-time equivalent qualified doctors; 9.5 qualified doctors; ratio of patients to qualified GP, 1,793.

The Village Surgery, New Barnet – 6,339 patients; 3.1 full-time equivalent qualified doctors; 3.1 qualified doctors; ratio of patients to qualified GP, 2,016.

Addington Medical Centre, New Barnet – 9,806 patients; 3.4 full-time equivalent qualified doctors; 3.4 qualified doctors; ratio of patients to qualified GP, 2842.

East Barnet Health Centre – 11,290 patients; 7.1 full-time equivalent qualified doctors; 6 qualified doctors; ratio of patients to qualified GP, 1,859.

Posted on — 1 Comment

Barnet Council faces dilemma over deteriorating state of condemned blocks of flats at Dollis Valley Estate

Barnet Council faces dilemma over deteriorating state of condemned blocks of flats at Dollis Valley Estate

Vandalised blocks of flats and maisonettes awaiting demolition are likely to remain an eyesore for months to come following the sudden and unexpected collapse of a deal previously approved by Barnet Council to complete the regeneration of the Dollis Valley Estate.

Homes which were condemned as unfit some years ago were about to be replaced by developers Vistry under a scheme which had qualified for a £58.85 million grant from the Greater London Authority.

In a rarely used procedure Barnet’s Conservative councillors called in the agreement on the grounds it lacked “financial sustainability” – a process which halted the deal and resulted in the loss of the GLA grant.

Barry Rawlings, Labour leader of the council, told the Barnet Society that it would be early next year or even later before it would be possible to come up with an alternative scheme.

Barnet Council faces dilemma over deteriorating state of condemned blocks of flats at Dollis Valley Estate

In the meantime, the council faces a dilemma. The cost of demolishing the flats and maisonettes, which was due to start in September, could be as high as £3 million – money which Councillor Rawlings said the council had not budgeted for.

The only alternative might be to fence off the whole site with secure hoardings to prevent access and deter further vandalism.

Barnet Council faces dilemma over deteriorating state of condemned blocks of flats at Dollis Valley Estate

Given the presence of squatters in some of empty flats and the general state of decay – with large pools of stagnant water formed by leaking pipes and mains – the owners of nearby houses on what is now the Brook Valley Gardens estate say they should not have to put up with such gruesome dereliction.

Conservative group leader Councillor Peter Zinkin recognised that the cost of securing the abandoned blocks of flats was high, but he thought the council probably had no option but to wait for the housing market to improve.

His preferred course of action – one backed by a Brook Valley Gardens residents’ group – was for the council to return to the original proposal to finish off the Dollis Valley regeneration with 126 new privately-owned and 95 affordable homes.

When Vistry declared this scheme was unviable, the council negotiated a fresh agreement with the developers to complete the regeneration with 208 new affordable homes, a deal which qualified for the £58.85 million GLA grant towards the cost of new affordable housing.

Once the renegotiated deal was called in by the Conservatives on the grounds it lacked “financial responsibility” the council was unable to meet the GLA’s deadline of Friday 31 July for approving the project and the offer of a grant was withdrawn.

A hurriedly arranged meeting was held on Tuesday 4 August at which a group of residents and the Barnet Society were excluded on the grounds that issues regarding the “financial responsibility and financial sustainability” of the council’s agreement with Vistry had to be discussed in private.

This was the first time for 14 years that the call-in procedure had been triggered and the Conservatives’ action was defended by Councillor Zinkin.

He said it was “really important” for the opposition to test whether the council’s cabinet had taken the “correct decision” in approving the Vistry deal.

In a note setting out their case, the Conservatives said the Vistry group was under severe financial strain, and they considered the cabinet meeting had not been provided with “sufficient assurance as to the financial viability and delivery risk” for the scale of the commitment.

Councillor Zinkin’s action in calling in the deal was supported by Peter Esposito who was allowed to ask questions on behalf of residents who were opposed to the latest Vistry scheme and who believed those who had purchased new houses had been misled about the GLA funding for the scheme.

These residents were against the Vistry agreement because it abandoned the original undertaking that 60 per cent of the new homes in the Dollis Valley regeneration would be privately owned with only 40 per cent available for social rent.

By switching the completion of phases 4 and 5 to the construction of 208 affordable homes, the balance would be reversed with only 40 per cent of the houses on the estate remaining privately owned, a proportion which they argued would make it more difficult to obtain mortgages and could depress the value of their properties.

Vandalised flats and maisonettes on Dollis Valley Estate will continue to be an eyesore following collapse of Barnet Council deal to build 208 new affordable homes

The Dollis Valley estate was built in the 1960s and 1970s and Barnet Council acknowledges that the five-storey blocks of flats and maisonettes suffered from many of the problems such as dampness and condensation which affect post-war estates.

The first three phases of the regeneration, with the construction of 408 homes of mixed tenure, was completed in 2023 but the council has been dogged with problems over agreeing a scheme to build the final 208 new homes.

The deal agreed with Vistry to build 187 homes for social rent and 21 for key workers for living rent – to be managed by Barnet Homes – was described by the council as the “only one viable option”.

Councillor Rawlings told the call-in meeting which probed the collapse of the deal that he did not think the issues raised in the scrutiny process did “materially affect the decision which was made”.

After the meeting he said he feared yet another delay in completing the Dollis Valley regeneration would create more uncertainty for those residents who had been moved out of their “unsafe and leaking flats” and transferred to other temporary council accommodation.

“These residents had been forgotten in all of this. When they were moved away, they were promised they would get a chance to move back to Dollis Valley.”

He said that the first three phases of the regeneration – and the creation of the new Brook Valley Gardens estate with 400 new homes – had been a success.

“Years back people used to say that Dollis Valley was a no-go estate, but the area has been transformed, and we are anxious to see that regeneration completed.”

Posted on — 2 Comments

Mayor Khan’s proposed London Plan puts pressure on Barnet

view of derelict Green Belt land near Stirling Corner
Mayor Khan’s proposed London Plan puts pressure on Barnet

Barely five years after Mayor Khan’s current London Plan came into force, he’s consulting on a new one. The good news is that it will be a lot slimmer than the present version. The bad news for Barnet is that he’s upping his target for new homes in our borough, and he’s identified places in the Green Belt where some of them could be built.

The draft new Plan was published in July and is open for comments until 15 October. Its housing target for Barnet is to build 32,730 new homes between 2028 & 2037 – a 38% increase on the present London Plan. That still won’t be enough to deliver the Labour government’s pledge of 1.5 million new homes over the lifetime of this parliament. The Mayor and other Labour politicians are increasingly keen to pull any levers that might boost housing supply.

Since brownfield sites within Barnet are limited and more expensive to build on, the Mayor wants the Council to build 7,000 homes in its Green Belt (see map below). He states a preference for using those parts of it deemed ‘Grey Belt’, which could include derelict land in Arkley such as the site illustrated above. But he acknowledges that some greenfield areas will have to be sacrificed.

Mayor Khan’s proposed London Plan puts pressure on Barnet

On his election as MP for Chipping Barnet, Dan Thomlinson said, ‘Our green spaces and the beautiful Green Belt here in this constituency is something that I will always fight for and protect’. We hope he still keeps that promise.

The Plan would require at least 50% of new homes in the Green Belt to be ‘affordable’, or 35% in the case of schemes for 10-35 homes. (Developments of fewer than 10 homes are exempt.) These are ambitious targets, significantly higher than normally offered by developers. If they can be achieved, the Barnet Society might consider that a reasonable trade-off for the loss of some poor-quality Green Belt.

The Plan would subject any residential development in the Green Belt to conditions. Notably, the vast majority of the new homes would have to be located either within 400m of an eligible bus route or 1.2km – 15 minutes’ walk – from one of seven ‘well-connected’ rail and tube stations in Barnet. But that puts most of the constituency of Chipping Barnet in the frame, i.e. from Arkley to Hadley, and from New Barnet to Whetstone.

In addition to these seven ‘broad locations for growth’ (BLGs), the draft Plan also identifies ‘future industrial-led Green Belt candidates’ around the A1 at Borehamwood. This could include the extensive tract of land north-east of Stirling Corner (pictured at the top of this post).

Other industrial-led sites are by the M25 in Enfield, possibly associated with a 21,000-home new town at Crews Hill. That proposal is supported by the government and the Mayor of London, though – since the May local elections – no longer by Enfield Council.

The Plan also sets out strategic criteria for the construction of additional data centres across London to meet the growing demand. These are typically enormous boxes that consume large quanties of electricity and water (for cooling).

The draft London Plan makes no mention of the proposal in Barnet’s Local Plan to create a new Regional Park on the Green Belt and Metropolitan Open Space stretching between Arkley, Scratchwood and Mill Hill. Unless kept to the absolute minimum necessary for sustainable management of the Park, residential or commercial development within this zone would defeat its whole point.

You can read more about these threats and opportunities in my previous web post on the Green Belt.

Barnet Council has declared its objection to the Mayor’s proposals for housing and the Green Belt, which contradict the Local Plan that it adopted only last year. Deputy Leader and Cabinet Member for Homes and Regeneration, Cllr Ross Houston, said:

“Barnet Council will carefully assess the detail of the draft London Plan before submitting its formal response to the consultation and we will continue to work with residents, communities and partners to ensure any future growth delivers the homes, opportunities and neighbourhoods that people need and want to see.”

Cllr Houston, the Barnet Society would be delighted to work with you, especially on the existential threat to our Green Belt.

Mayor Khan’s proposed London Plan puts pressure on Barnet

Above: Cllr Ross Houston speaking at a Barnet Society public meeting on housing in Barnet in 2023

You can view the draft Plan here. Tell Mayor Khan your views by doing one of the following:

– write to Sadiq Khan, Mayor of London, Draft London Plan, London Plan Team, Planning & Regeneration, City Hall, Kamal Chunchie Way, London, E16 1ZE.

The deadline for comments is 5pm on Thursday, 15 October 2026.

Mayor Khan’s proposed London Plan puts pressure on Barnet
Posted on — 2 Comments

Public excluded from special Barnet Council meeting when councillors probed financial failure of controversial Dollis Valley housing scheme

Public excluded from special Barnet Council meeting when councillors probed financial failure of controversial Dollis Valley housing scheme

Fresh proposals are unlikely to emerge until at least the New Year for the completion of the Dollis Valley regeneration following the call-in and collapse of a scheme previously agreed by Barnet Council to build 208 new affordable homes on the estate.

Residents from Dollis Valley – and the Barnet Society – were excluded from a part of a special call-in meeting when a sub-committee of councillors considered financial issues surrounding the failed scheme.

Before members of the public were asked to leave, the leader of the Conservative group, Councillor Peter Zinkin, told the meeting why they had called in the deal agreed in July between the Labour-controlled council and developers Vistry.

He said the decision taken by the council’s cabinet was contrary to “financial responsibility and financial sustainability” and in their judgement those issues were “sufficient to go over the line and lack financial responsibility”.

It would be up to the committee to decide whether the judgement of Conservative councillors was correct, but Councillor Zinkin said it was “really important” for the opposition to test whether the deal with Vistry was the “correct decision”, concerns which had prompted them to call in a decision for the first time in 14 years.

In a note setting out their case, the six Conservative councillors said the developers Vistry were under severe financial strain and the council’s cabinet had not been provided with “sufficient assurance as to the financial viability and delivery risk” for the scale of the commitment. 

Public excluded from special Barnet Council meeting when councillors probed financial failure of controversial Dollis Valley housing scheme

After an hour-and-a-half discussion, the sub-committee decided the council would undertake a comprehensive financial assessment of all future options for completing the Dollis Valley regeneration.

An undertaking was given that future redevelopment would be in the interests of the existing residents whose views would be properly considered through the Dollis Valley Partnership Board.

Complaints about the lack of consultation with residents about the decision to build 208 affordable homes – qualifying for a £58.85 million grant from the Greater London Authority – had triggered a protest petition at an earlier council meeting. 

Public excluded from special Barnet Council meeting when councillors probed financial failure of controversial Dollis Valley housing scheme

Dollis Valley resident Peter Esposito – above left with Councillor Peter Zinkin – opened the meeting with a question about why residents had been misled about the GLA funding.

The cabinet meeting was told the grant decision was pending but he said council officers knew it had already been approved, and the public had been misinformed.

In his presentation Councillor Zinkin reinforced criticism of the way the cabinet meeting had been conducted.

A scrutiny committee was not called until 24 hours before the decision and a paper answering questions which had been raised was not provided until 17 minutes before cabinet met.

Public excluded from special Barnet Council meeting when councillors probed financial failure of controversial Dollis Valley housing scheme

In reply, Councillor Barry Rawlings (above) agreed there should have been more distance between the meetings, but he insisted the issues which came up during the scrutiny process did not “materially affect the decision which was made”.

The deal agreed with Vistry to build 187 homes for social rent and 21 for key workers was the “only one viable option”.

As a result of the call-in and the withdrawal of the £58.85 million GLA grant, the council would have to go over the options once again.

Given the difficult housing market Councillor Rawlings thought it would be difficult to find another viable scheme immediately and it would be next year before a decision could be made on how best to complete the Dollis Valley regeneration.

Public excluded from special Barnet Council meeting when councillors probed financial failure of controversial Dollis Valley housing scheme

In response to the Barnet Society, Councillor Zinkin said that he thought the best course of action in the circumstances was to demolish the vacant and vandalised blocks of flats and maisonettes which were deemed unfit three years ago.

“The cost of securing the abandoned housing is high. Demolition is definitely the preferred option while the council waits for the housing market to improve.

Councillor Zinkin said it might be possible in the future to get much closer to the original scheme to finish off the Dollis Valley regeneration with 126 new privately-owned and 95 affordable homes – a scheme which Vistry had said was unviable.

Peter Esposito and other Dollis Valley residents agreed that returning to the scheme which was originally approved by Dollis Valley Partnership Board was also their preferred option.

Fresh proposals unlikely before New Year to complete regeneration of Dollis Valley after collapse of deal between Barnet Council and developers Vistry

Councillor Rawlings said it was too early to speculate on what action might be taken but the council had estimated that the cost of demolishing the vacant blocks of flats and maisonettes and clearing the site could be as high as £3million.

His concern was that yet another delay in completing Dollis Valley was creating yet more uncertainty for those residents who had been moved out of the “unsafe and leaking flats” and transferred into other temporary council accommodation.

“These residents have been forgotten in all of this. When they were moved away, they were promised they would get a chance to move back to Dollis Valley”.

Councillor Rawlings said the regeneration of Dollis Valley – now known as the Brook Valley Gardens estate – had been a success with the construction of 400 new homes.

“Years back people used to say that Dollis Valley was a no-go estate, but the area has been transformed with regeneration and we are anxious to see that completed.” 

Posted on — 3 Comments

Dollis Valley redevelopment delayed yet again after Barnet Council loses out on £58 million Greater London housing grant

Dollis Valley redevelopment delayed yet again after Barnet Council loses out on £58 million Greater London housing grant

Barnet Council has had to abandon an immediate go ahead for the final stage of the Dollis Valley redevelopment following the sudden withdrawal of a £58.85 million grant from the Greater London Authority for building new affordable homes.

A council cabinet decision two weeks ago to proceed with the construction of 208 new homes – despite protests from some of the residents – has been called in for further discussion.

As a result, the council has failed to meet the GLA’s deadline of July 31 for approving the project.

Conservative councillors demanded that the cabinet’s decision should be called in – and therefore postponed – because of their concerns about the financial viability of the scheme and the lack of adequate consultation with residents.

Council officials will now have to draw up fresh proposals for the completion of what has become the Brook Valley Gardens estate.

Vacant blocks of flats and maisonettes – see above – have been awaiting demolition for the last three years and this fresh postponement is only the latest setback in a long, drawn-out saga.

Dollis Valley redevelopment delayed yet again after Barnet Council loses out on £58 million Greater London housing grant

A group of Brook Valley Gardens residents – where 60 per cent of the 400 homes are privately owned – have fought a sustained campaign against the council’s decision to finish off the estate with 208 affordable homes.

They say this would result in the estate having 60 per cent of homes for social rent which they argue is a breach of the undertakings they were given when they bought their homes and were told it would be 60 per cent privately owned.

Under the scheme approved by the cabinet on July 21 the council said it had reached an agreement with developers Vistry to construct 208 affordable homes which would be managed for the council by Barnet Homes.

To qualify for access to £58.85 million of GLA affordable housing grant the scheme had to be approved by July 31.

In confirming the funding was no longer available, the GLA said there was no longer “sufficient certainty” the grant conditions could be met and there were other schemes around London which could qualify.   

Barnet Council has to abandon immediate completion of Dollis Valley redeveopment following withdrawal of GLA affordable housing grant of £58 million in another setback to troubled scheme.

Demolition of the block of flats and maisonettes deemed unfit for occupation and a start on the construction of the new homes was due to begin in September.  

When approving this plan two weeks ago, the cabinet meeting acknowledged the “potential guilt” felt by some councillors for letting down the private owners.

What cabinet members and council officials had not taken into account was the determination of the private residents’ group to press for the decision to be called in.

Once this action was taken by Conservative councillors, council officials were no longer in a position to give the guarantees which were needed by the GLA over access to the £58.85 million grant.

A full report on the setback is to be considered by the council’s call-in sub-committee on Tuesday 4 August.

Residents who have been consulted by the Dollis Valley Partnership Board have welcomed the news that the grant is “no longer available” and say it has strengthened their argument for the council to start again and undertake meaningful discussions with them.

Among the financial issues facing the call-in sub-committee will be the demand for more information about the council’s contribution to finishing off the Dollis Valley estate – said to be another £40 million.

Unless the deal with Vistry can be renegotiated, the council might be left with no other option but to demolish the vacant blocks and clear the site with the hope that conditions in the housing market might improve or that the site can be sold to a private developer.

Posted on — 2 Comments

Redevelopment of Dollis Valley estate due to restart in September after three-year delay in demolishing vacant flats

Redevelopment of Dollis Valley estate due to restart in September after three-year delay in demolishing vacant flats

Completion of the redevelopment of the Dollis Valley estate – where blocks of flats and maisonettes have been awaiting demolition for the last three years – is finally to go ahead with access to a £58 million grant from the Greater London Authority.

Regeneration of the estate was stalled in 2023 because the developers Vistry said the scheme previously agreed with Barnet Council for 126 new privately-owned and 95 affordable homes was no longer viable.

A revised plan approved at a cabinet meeting will now provide for the construction of 208 affordable homes which will be managed for the council by Barnet Homes.

The new Dollis Valley houses – 187 for social rent and 21 for key workers – will provide what is described as a “significant” contribution to Barnet’s target to deliver 1,000 new council homes.

But by abandoning the previously agreed construction of over 100 new private homes, the council has angered owners of new Dollis Valley houses who fear this will alter the balance of an estate which was supposed to be a 50/50 split between private and social ownership.

Despite what was described at the meeting as the “potential guilt” felt by some councillors for letting down the private owners, the cabinet decided there was no other viable option than to accept Vistry’s latest proposal.

To qualify for access to £58.85 million of GLA affordable housing grant, construction of the new houses has to start by September this year.

Redevelopment of Dollis Valley estate due to restart in September after three-year delay in demolishing vacant flats

If the council failed to meet the deadline one option would be to demolish the vacant flats and maisonettes and retain the empty site until the housing market improved but that would expose the council to further financial risk.

The first three phases of the Dollis Valley regeneration have delivered over 400 new houses in what the council describes as “a low-rise, gentle density garden suburb style development dominated by houses with gardens and traditional streets.”

Dollis Valley regeneration to restart after Barrnet Council agrees new deal with developers Vistry for 221 new homes

The final two phases of the scheme – which would result in the demolition of the vacant Garrowsfield and Mill Bridge blocks – were originally intended to provide 126 private and 95 affordable homes.

Poor market conditions and increased construction costs were said to have made this “significantly unviable” which resulted in Vistry proposing the construction of 208 affordable homes at “a fixed price” and 13 private homes, the scheme which has now been approved.

Posted on — 6 Comments

Approval for new High Street retail premises and housing at junction with Moxon Street as demolition underway on two other nearby developments

Approval for new High Street retail premises and housing at junction with Moxon Street as demolition underway on two other nearby developments

Planning approval has finally been given after four years of negotiations and discussions for a new four-storey building at a prominent site in Barnet town centre at the corner of High Street and Moxon Street.

Architect Simon Kaufman is confident the new building – see above – with 11 new homes over commercial premises with a traditional shop front will enhance the character of a site at the heart of the Wood Street Conservation Area.

Moxon Street itself is currently being transformed by new housing developments.

Demolition is underway at the former Checkalow Tiles showroom, where there will be 21 new homes, and at the much larger site of the former Intec House, where there is approval for a new block of flats.

Approval for new High Street retail premises and housing at junction with Moxon Street as demolition underway on two other nearby developments

Discussions over how to redevelop the two empty shop premises at the corner of High Street and Moxon Street – where there had been a photo-copying business, a Foxtons estate agency and then a community pop-up shop – began six years ago.

Simon Kaufman Architects consulted planners, conservation officers, the Barnet Society, nearby residents and other local stakeholders.

“A collaborative design process has helped shape a scheme which responds positively to both the site and its historic setting while delivering an exciting new future for this important High Street building,” said Mr Kaufman.

Once the planning application was submitted, negotiations with Barnet Council’s planning department took another four years.

“This has been a long journey.”

“It is tremendously rewarding to see this prominent High Street building restored and given a new lease of life, making a positive contribution to the local community once again.

“The approved design carefully restores and enhances its historic character through the recreation of a traditional shop front, sensitive restoration of the masonry and architectural detailing, and a carefully designed roof extension that complements the historic townscape.

“This will bring 11 new homes, fresh investment and new life to this important part of Chipping Barnet.”

Dan Tomlinson, MP for Chipping Barnet, said he had worked closely with Simon Kaufman Architects to ensure that the site – 98-100 High Street – was brought back into life after such a long delay.

“This site spent years stuck in process and paperwork, and it was my intervention that finally stopped the administrative ping-pong.

“I am over the moon that through hard work, alongside my team, Simon Kaufman Architects, and local groups like the Barnet Society, we will finally see this eyesore turned into a new retail site and, most importantly, housing for residents.”

Approval for new High Street retail premises and housing at junction with Moxon Street as demolition underway on two other nearby developments

Demolition work is now underway on the Checkalow site in Moxon Street where a car-free mews with two rows of terraced homes is to be built to provide a total of 21 new homes for Barnet Homes.

The new tree-lined mews will connect Moxon Street to Tapster Street and will be open to pedestrians but have no access for motor vehicles.

Half the new one- and two-bedroom houses will be affordable housing, some perhaps under shared ownership.

Planning approval granted for new retail premises and housing at High Street corner with Moxon Street as demolition is underway on two other nearby housing developments

Demolition of the former Intec House, a three-storey office block, will make way for the construction of a six-storey block of 113 homes of which 17 will be for social rent.

Approval for the redevelopment by Moxon One Ltd was given by Barnet Council in October 2024 despite opposition from some nearby residents in South Close who fear that because of its height the new block will overlook their homes.

Top image Simon Kaufman Architects

Posted on

Planning Inspector dismisses appeal to build mansion in Christchurch Lane spinney

??????????

An Inspector has dismissed an appeal by developer Christchurchgrove Ltd against Barnet Council’s refusal of its planning application to build a 5-bedroom house in a wood in Chipping Barnet. The decision concludes a successful campaign by local residents, with help from the Barnet Society, to save a cherished natural habitat in the Monken Hadley Conservation Area. It also sends a message to developers about the Council’s commitment to protecting green spaces in Barnet.

Although only one acre in area, the spinney beside Christchurch Lane forms a link in a green chain connecting Old Fold Manor golf course and Hadley Green, both in the Green Belt. Both are also designated Areas of Particular Importance for Biodiversity in the Mayor of London’s Nature Recovery Plan. Many trees in the wood are subject to Tree Preservation Orders (TPOs) and it is a haven of wild life, for example the Muntjac deer and her fawn in the photograph above (courtesy of neighbour Marianne Nix).

Planning Inspector dismisses appeal to build mansion in Christchurch Lane spinney

Concerns arose two years ago, when it emerged that the Council had authorised the sale of the part of the spinney that it owns for £430,000, subject to the buyer obtaining planning consent. But its own planning and biodiversity officers took issue with aspects of the preliminary ecological appraisal commissioned by the developer and breaches of Barnet’s Local Plan.

In parallel local residents monitored wildlife in the wood, photographing and recording a fascinating range of birds, bats and animals coming and going within 200 metres of Barnet High Street (as reported in our web post on 31 January). A petition to Save Chipping Barnet Woodland was started in September 2025, and within a few months had been supported by over 2,250 signatures. 

A planning application was eventually submitted in January this year. It comprised a new mansion, designed in the Arts & Crafts style of existing houses in Sunset View, with a private garden and an enclosed swimming pool. In response to Society suggestions, the house boundaries were softened to integrate the garden more closely with the existing vegetation, and a plan was offered to manage the whole of the spinney. Despite constructive pre-application discussions between the developer and the Society, however, the final proposals did not go far enough to safeguard the existing environment and we objected to them – as did 278 other members of the public. Not a single comment was submitted in support.

Barnet planners recommended refusal of the application. Not only did the application breach several policies in its Local Plan (adopted only last year), it would have contradicted the Green Manifesto which had formed part of Labour’s platform in the 2022 local elections. Perhaps with an eye on the impending May local elections, the Council rejected the application on 10 March.

Almost immediately, the developer appealed against the Council’s decision.

The Planning Inspectorate’s verdict, published on 10 July, is unambiguous:

‘…the development of the site would have a harmful impact on the character and appearance of the area…and would fail to preserve the character or appearance of the Monken Hadley Conservation Area [MHCA]’, as well as being contrary to policies in The London Plan and the Barnet Local Plan.’

The Inspector echoed the opinion of local residents:

‘The sense of depth and scale that the woodland currently possesses is of considerable value…It provides a characterful wooded setting to the adjacent development and ties these roads into the wider landscape character of the MHCA…’

S/he also noted that,

‘This impact would be exacerbated by the proposed design…the proposed dwelling would appear to sit within an overgrown garden without a clear visual and spatial connection to the road or the sense of grandeur that many dwellings in the area possess.’

Regarding the hedge proposed around the site perimeter, the Inspector commented,

‘It is however highly doubtful that it would be possible to plant and successfully establish a continuous hedge in this location given the number of trees that would be retained around the edges of the site and their scale.’

Furthermore,

‘…the value of the woodland and the presence of a veteran tree, have not been accurately assessed, resulting in an unreliable biodiversity net gain calculation.’

The Society and campaigners have welcomed the Inspector’s decision. Retired GP Richard Norris commented,

‘Very definite rejection from Planning Inspector Tucker, very detailed, gives me faith in our institutions.’

Marianne Nix, who was instrumental in setting up the Save Chipping Barnet Woodland website and petition said,

‘I am delighted and hugely relieved that the Planning Inspectorate has dismissed the Appeal. The local community has worked together tirelessly to raise funds to publicise and to fight the potential destruction of this precious pocket of green on our doorsteps. Together we have gained the support of thousands of Barnet residents as well as petition signatures from all parts of the UK and even overseas. The World is waking up to the fact that we need to protect even the smallest pockets of nature and biodiversity that we in Barnet are lucky enough to enjoy.’

She thanked everyone who had objected to the planning application. But she went on to warn,

‘Although the veteran trees and wildlife are safe for now, I have a feeling there will be another application, this time with two or three houses.’

So we can’t relax. The Barnet Society was founded specifically to protect London’s Green Belt and the wider environment, and these are under greater threat than ever. We need funds to continue doing so. If you haven’t done so already, please join us or donate – just go to the top of this page.

Planning Inspector dismisses appeal to build mansion in Christchurch Lane spinney
Posted on — 2 Comments

Deputy Mayor of London has high praise for a new High Barnet estate of houses and flats being built on former farmland at Whalebones

Deputy Mayor of London has high praise for a new High Barnet estate of houses and flats being built on former farmland at Whalebones

Construction of new houses and flats is well underway on what was the last remaining field on the border betweenHigh High Barnet and Arkley – a development described by a Deputy Mayor of London as a “fantastic example” of delivering new homes while preserving a green space and respecting the heritage of the location.

Work on the new Whalebones Park housing estate began last year after those campaigning to preserve the Whalebones woods and farmland finally admitted defeat.

Barnet Council voted narrowly in favour of the scheme and the Mayor of London gave the final go-ahead for the construction of 115 new homes, a mix of houses for private sale and affordable homes in blocks ranging from two to five storeys in height.

The first of the new homes are expected to be completed by the summer next year.

Deputy Mayor of London praises controversial redevelopment on farmland at Whalebones for its contribution to providing the high quality and affordable homes needed by Londoners

Tom Copley, deputy mayor of London for housing and development, was welcomed on an official visit to the site by Greg Hill, deputy chief executive of the developers, The Hill Group, and Joe Mashall, chief investment and development officer for affordable housing charity Sovereign Network Group.

(Hill Group photo, See above, Tom Copley, with spade, and on his left London Assembly Member Councillor Ann Clarke and Greg Hill; and on his right, High Barnet Councillor Emma Whysall and Joe Marshall).

The purpose of the visit was to review progress on a development aimed at addressing London’s housing need while “preserving and enhancing” the character of an important heritage site.

Mr Copley praised the commitment of the Hill Group and SNG in preserving green space around the development and enhancing biodiversity.

“Whalebones Park is a fantastic example of how we can deliver the high-quality, genuinely affordable homes Londoners need while creating places where communities can thrive,” said Mr Copley.

“Developments like this are vital to building a better, fairer London.”

Mr Marshall said a total of 54 affordable homes – one, two and three-bedroom apartments – would be delivered through a partnership between The Hill Group and SNG and they would give local people greater access to affordable rent and shared ownership in an area where demand remained high.

“Combined with the new green spaces, community facilities and long-term investment in the landscape, this development will make a lasting positive impact for both new and existing residents.”  

Andy Hill, founder and group chief executive of The Hill Group, has always insisted the Whalebones Park development will respect the heritage of the Grade II listed Whalebones House, formerly the home of Cowing family, proprietors of the Barnet Press.

Around half of the 12 acre-site will be retained as publicly accessible open space, “ensuring the natural beauty and heritage of Whalebones Park is protected for future generations”.

“Residents and the wider community will benefit from attractive meadows, healing gardens, ponds, natural play areas, a woodland walk and accessible routes.”

A biodiversity net gain of 10 per cent would be achieved through the planting of 200 new trees and 750 metres of new hedgerow, alongside a long-term management plan to protect habitats and green infrastructure.

The new homes will feature air-source heat pumps, solar panels and sustainable urban drainage systems to ensure the neighbourhood is “low carbon, energy efficient and environmentally sensitive”.

The development will retain a site for an agricultural smallholding to replace the original Whalebones farm; a new community building including a new studio for Barnet Guild of Artists; and one site parking.  

Posted on — 5 Comments

Up went the hands in favour of Barnet Society members contributing to any appeal to fund a legal challenge to High Barnet station flats

Up went the hands in favour of Barnet Society members contributing to any appeal to fund a legal challenge to High Barnet station flats

Barnet Society members have voted decisively to support and contribute to any campaign to mount a legal challenge against the Deputy Mayor of London’s decision to overrule Barnet Council and authorise the go ahead for blocks of flats on the car park at High Barnet tube station.

The deadline for an application for a judicial review is Tuesday 7 July.

Although Barnet Council has yet to announce if it has any intention of challenging the mayor’s decision in the High Court, Barnet Residents Association says it is seeking advice on whether there might be grounds for pursuing a judicial review.

When asked for their response at the annual general meeting of the Barnet Society, members voted unanimously in favour of the society contributing towards the cost of an application for judicial review.

There was also a unanimous vote by those who were present to contribute personally to a legal fund – and half the members who were there indicated they would contribute £100 each if necessary.

Robin Bishop (above), the society’s lead on planning issues, told the meeting that possible grounds for judicial review might be that the deputy mayor had pre-judged the application and ignored Barnet’s local plan which limited the height of any blocks to seven storeys – when the proposed scheme included one tower block of 11 storeys.

A High Court challenge would be costly: initial legal advice would amount to around several thousand pounds, and a full legal challenge could cost around £40,000, which might double if costs had to be paid to Transport for London.

Up went the hands in favour of Barnet Society members contributing to any appeal to fund a legal challenge to High Barnet station flats

Committee member Nick Saul (above, left) advised the meeting that the deputy mayor’s decision could be challenged on the grounds it was a test case when it came to applications to build on Transport for London land.

Calling in the High Barnet station scheme for the mayor’s approval was not a first in itself, but was the first to be considered and decided upon at a hearing at City Hall.

Similar applications for developments at Stanmore and Canons Park stations were called in, but both were withdrawn before a hearing took place.

An alternative suggestion made at the meeting was that local groups might launch a petition to persuade Barnet Council to declare the station car park as an asset of community value – a step which would prevent the land being developed by TfL’s investment subsidiary Places for London and developers Barratt.

Mr Bishop promised to keep the society abreast of any moves within the community to launch a judicial review and consider other options such as seeking ACV status for the car park to block the scheme – a safeguard that would remain in place for around 5 years.

The possibility of getting involved in legal action only served to underline the significance of a separate decision at the annual meeting to prepare the necessary documents for an application to convert the society into a company limited by guarantee.

Barnet Society members ready to support and contribute any fund to mount legal challenge to Deputy Mayor of London's decision to give go ahead for blocks of flats over High Barnet tube station car park.

Committee member Mahender Khari (above) explained the importance to voluntary community groups of taking advantage of the legal protection which this structure offered to committee members.

Increasingly non-profit groups such as charities and clubs were becoming a company limited by guarantee because it created an up-to-date and more stable financial structure and assisted when seeking grants or other funding.

Mr Khari thanked the annual meeting for their support and said the committee would now proceed with the preparation of the paperwork which would be needed to register with Companies House.

Once the documentation had been completed it would be sent out to members before being voted on at an extra-ordinary general meeting.

John Hay, the society’s chair – who is also trustee treasurer for the Friends of Tudor Park and Pavilion – told the meeting that there had been some progress at last on the bid to rescue and renovate the abandoned former cricket pavilion.

A head of agreement had been settled with Barnet Council and the friends’ committee was waiting to sign an agreement to lease the pavilion.

Once that step had been completed there would be a chance to examine the state of the building – at heightened risk because of a widening crack on the west elevation – and that could lead on to a signing of the lease itself.

Mr Hay acknowledged the frustration over the time this was taking but the council had now agreed that no rent would be charged on the pavilion for the first five years, followed by a pepper corn rent, and that £191,000 was available in a fund set aside by the council for repairs.

Posted on — 2 Comments

Park Quarter flats reshaping New Barnet as final deadline approaches over proposed high-rise blocks of flats at High Barnet station

Park Quarter flats reshaping New Barnet as final deadline approaches over proposed high-rise blocks of flats at High Barnet station

Construction of a massive complex of nearly 500 new flats at New Barnet is reaching the half-way stage – just as the go-ahead for the start of a proposed high-rise development at High Barnet tube station might be only weeks away.

Eleven blocks of up to eight storeys in height are being constructed by Fairview New Homes on the site of the former New Barnet gas works off Albert Road.

With almost 100 flats having now been sold, the new Park Quarter estate is rapidly taking shape.

Approval for the New Barnet scheme was a long and drawn-out affair and almost as tortuous and contentious as the highly-controversial plan to build five blocks of flats – including one of 11 storeys – over the tube station car park and container yard.

Any legal challenge to the decision by the Deputy Mayor of London, Jules Pipe, to approve the High Barnet scheme must be made by mid-July.

Advice on whether to seek a judicial review is being taken into consideration by Barnet Council and separately by Barnet Residents Association.

So far, the council’s only response, from the deputy leader Councillor Ross Houston, is “no comment at this stage”.

However, privately, some councillors with knowledge of the High Barnet scheme, says they do not think that realistically there are any legal grounds on which the Deputy Mayor of London’s decision can be challenged.

Although the council’s strategic planning committee voted by a clear majority against the tube station blocks of flats due to concern over their “scale, height and density”, planning officers had originally recommended approval as the site was allocated for residential-led redevelopment and would provide 328 new homes of which 100 would be affordable.

If the July deadline passes with no application to the High Court, developers Barratt and Transport for London’s investment subsidiary, Places for London, hope to start construction at High Barnet in February next year.

Park Quarter flats reshaping New Barnet as final deadline approaches over proposed high-rise blocks of flats at High Barnet station

At Park Quarter in New Banet access to the site is about to be opened up with a new a new footpath into the development from the Victoria Recreation Ground – see Fairview image above – which should be completed by the end of June.

“Opening up the development onto Victoria Recreation Ground, creating a stronger physical and visual connection with the surrounding neighbourhood, will help the scheme become an ever more integrated part of the local community,” said Mark Jackson, Fairview director of planning.

Park Quarter flats reshaping New Barnet as final deadline approaches over proposed high-rise blocks of flats at High Barnet station

An official topping out ceremony at the highest point of the development had achieved what Mr Jackson believed was a “significant construction milestone” for a scheme which appealed to people with strong connections to the local community.

Park Quarter had already attracted 93 buyers, including 69 first-time purchasers of whom 15 were from the local area.

Phase one of the 486-home Park Quarter development, which began in summer 2023, was sold out within ten months and work on phase two was well underway with 36 homes ready for occupation from March.

A further 106 homes are due to be finished by the end of the year and the entire development completed by the autumn of 2028.

Included in the development are one-, two- and three-bedroom homes and apartments and two- and three-bedroom duplexes; 162 of the flats will be affordable, at social rent or shared ownership, under the management of SNG Housing.

In line with the planning approval, Fairview have removed a footbridge which used to connect to a tunnel under the main railway line – a regular access route for pedestrians between Victoria Recreation Ground and Cromer Road.

Park Quarter development of nearly 500 flats at New Barnet reaches half way stage as deadline nears for legal challenge to high rise blocks of flats at High Barnet tube station.

In its place is a new footpath leading to the railway tunnel – an improvement welcomed by East Barnet councillor Simon Radford who is now in discussion with Network Rail to carry out repair work to sort out leaking surface water from the railway track above. 

Under obligations placed on Fairview’s planning approval, the scheme has required contributions of £1.5 million, including support for local bus services and for a controlled parking zone review and scheme.

In addition the development is subject to a community infrastructure levy of over £5.7 million, of which £4.3 million is paid to Barnet Council for local improvements.

Posted on — 3 Comments

Campaign to save and rebuild an abandoned clubhouse for benefit of Underhill residents gathers pace ahead of its sale by Barnet Council

Campaign to save and rebuild an abandoned clubhouse for benefit of Underhill residents gathers pace ahead of its sale by Barnet Council

Residents around Mays Lane are anxious to attract support for a community bid to take over the derelict former Quinta Youth Club which has been put up for sale by Barnet Council for £300,000.

Local groups have until October to submit offers and proposals to the council. Several eligible community interest organisations have already expressed interest.

Gina Theodorou (above), chair of the Quinta Village Green Residents Association, is appealing for a concerted push by the locality to help to secure and re-open the derelict club as a community hub and space.

“We fear Barnet Council may favour selling the abandoned building to an organisation from outside the area rather than a genuinely local community-led proposal.

“Our aim is to create a flexible new community building and integrate it into Quinta village green which is alongside and which we have already made sure is preserved for the use of our community.”

As a first step a community interest company is to be established by the residents’ association to develop a business plan.

Campaign to save and rebuild an abandoned clubhouse for benefit of Underhill residents gathers pace ahead of its sale by Barnet Council

An image, showing what a revived Quinta Club building might look like, has been issued in support of an appeal on Facebook and GoFundMe to help with the cost of planning and funding the application:

The club building – originally constructed by the Underhill community in the 1960s with the help of local tradesmen and residents – has been derelict for the last 20 years, raising concern among Mays Lane residents about continuing vandalism and anti-social behaviour.

Campaign to save and rebuild an abandoned clubhouse for benefit of Underhill residents gathers pace ahead of its sale by Barnet Council

Gina Theodorou – seen above with Rory (16) who is supporting the campaign for a new community space for local youngsters – is urging the community to rally round as quickly as possible so that a proposal can be submitted to the council by the deadline of October 17.

“In its heyday the Quinta Club was a wonderful community space – it was a youth centre, a meeting place for the elderly, for a nursery and for all sorts of exercise classes.

“We are becoming increasingly concerned because the council is getting expressions of interest from community groups outside the area– including religious organisations – and the priority for the council seems to be getting rid of the freehold for the best possible price.

“We want to keep the building as broad-based shared community asset, which is financially sustainable and offer affordable room hire, café, and space for family and youth activities.”  

It was at the request of residents’ association that the abandoned building was registered by the council as an asset of community value.

This has established a six-month moratorium during which the council may only sell the former club to a qualifying community interest group – a window of opportunity which lasts until October 17.

Campaign to save and rebuild an abandoned clubhouse for benefit of Underhill residents gathers pace ahead of its sale by Barnet Council

An open day will be held at the site in Mays Lane on Tuesday 30 June (from 11am to 2pm) when qualifying groups can view the property and ask questions, although there is a warning that viewing might be limited to “an external walk around on grounds of safety”.

To build up support for its GoFundMe appeal and a combined local response, Mrs Theodorou is hoping to draw on professional expertise within the community and wider backing from local politicians.

Dan Tomlinson, the MP for Chipping Barnet, launched a Community Action Network in March this year, aimed at “shaping and showcasing” projects proposed by the local residents in his constituency.

Mays Lane is within the council’s Underhill ward and one of its two councillors, Zahra Beg, is the newly elected Mayor of Barnet.   

Campaign to mount a bid for community to rebuild the Quinta Club in Mays Lane which Barnet Council has put on the market for £300,000 with deadline of October for community bids

Ms Theodorou says residents have been become alarmed at the state of the dereliction.

There are gaps in the boarding surrounding the derelict building and it has become a dumping ground for rubbish.

After its success in getting Quinta village green registered as a public open space, the residents’ association liaises with the council to ensure maintenance of the green and to ensure that fly tipping is removed.

Posted on — 28 Comments

Promise of 100 affordable new homes influences final go ahead for tower blocks at High Barnet tube station and loss of car parking

Promise of 100 affordable new homes influences final go ahead for tower blocks at High Barnet tube station and loss of car parking

Approval has finally been given by the office of the Mayor of London for the redevelopment of land around High Barnet tube station with five blocks of flats despite warnings this would cause irreparable damage to an historic skyline.

A deputation from the town’s community groups told a hearing at City Hall that squeezing 328 new homes into a narrow strip of land between the tube line and the Barnet Hill trunk road was the “wrong scale in the wrong place”.

Promise of 100 affordable new homes influences final go ahead for tower blocks at High Barnet tube station and loss of car parking

Objections were overruled by Jules Pipe, Deputy Mayor for Planning and Regeneration, who said that although three of the blocks would exceed the seven-storey limit agreed in the Barnet local plan – and one block would be 11 storeys – the impact of the height and massing of the flats would be negligible on the neighbourhood and no reason for refusal.

Building more affordable homes was the mayor’s priority and the High Barnet Place scheme would provide 100 new homes at low-cost rent or shared ownership.

“We must take advantage of sites which offer a high proportion of affordable homes and where the key travel infra-structure is in place,” said Mr Pipe.

“Inevitably schemes like High Barnet Place would be visible, including long range views…but the alternative would be to drive such schemes to the green belt and to less sustainable sites.”

Objections to the loss 160 spaces in the station car park – and the provision of only eight places for Blue Badge holders – were rejected by Mr Pipe on the grounds that encouraging tube passengers to walk to the station or take a bus would encourage “more sustainable means of travel and improve air quality”.

Developers Barratt and Transport for London’s investment subsidiary, Places for London, hope to start construction in February next year with the first affordable homes being available in February 2029 and the scheme completed by April 2030.

Mayor of London's office gives final go ahead for blocks of flats around High Barnet Station, Key factor 100 new affordable homes, a priority for the Mayor but station will lose its car park.

Simon Kaufman, a chartered architect (above, second from right), made a joint presentation on behalf of members of the Barnet Society and Barnet Residents Association.

He said many of the flats in the five tower blocks would be of poor quality, single aspect and reliant on mechanical ventilation.

The design of the scheme exemplified the social and management failures of high-density blocks of flats built across London in the 1960s and 1970s.

After Mr Pipe announced the scheme would go ahead, Mr Kaufman said the conscience of the objectors was clear.

“We listened to the lessons of history, and we are not prepared to see a repeat of the mistakes of the past. We did our best to prevent a development which we fear will become a disaster in years to come.”

Promise of 100 affordable new homes influences final go ahead for tower blocks at High Barnet tube station and loss of car parking

Neil Smith, senior project planning officer for the Greater London Authority, opened the hearing by reminding the Deputy Mayor that Barnet Council had refused permission for the blocks of flats because of their excessive height and harm to the character of the surrounding area.

However, the GLA considered the height and massing of the blocks responded well to the immediate context and would make “a positive contribution to the local townscape”.

Given the loss of the car park, there would be nine drop off short-stay spaces and eight Blue Badge spaces, but otherwise the development would be car-free with an enhanced public footpath on the station approach.

A significant public benefit of the scheme would be 100 affordable new homes and there were “no material considerations of sufficient weight to justify refusal”.

Promise of 100 affordable new homes influences final go ahead for tower blocks at High Barnet tube station and loss of car parking

In opening for the objectors Simon Kaufman said that when seen from the surrounding green belt countryside the proposed tower blocks harmed the historic skyline of High Barnet where the defining landmark on the hill had been the parish church.

“This is an over-scaled urban insertion imposed on to an historic hill town.”

An issue which eroded public confidence was that many residents were troubled by the fact Transport for London was effectively promoting development on its own land while the Greater London Authority and the Mayor of London were the decision-maker.

Promise of 100 affordable new homes influences final go ahead for tower blocks at High Barnet tube station and loss of car parking

Mr Kaufman criticised the removal of the station car park without providing a realistic alternative and the steep topography of the station approach meant that women, older residents and disabled users would continue to face intimidating routes, particularly after dark.

Promise of 100 affordable new homes influences final go ahead for tower blocks at High Barnet tube station and loss of car parking

Janet Littlewood of Barnet Residents Association, speaking on behalf of Gordon Massey, said the blocks of flats on the site would add to the existing chaos on the station approach where there were often traffic jams.

The area around the station was isolated and many women would not leave the station unless they could exit by car.

Nick Saul, a retired civil engineer, warned that the loss of the car park and the failure to provide bus access to the station forecourt raised serious concerns for women and the disabled.

Serious assaults to passengers when on foot or on cycle were not uncommon where parking had already been lost at tube stations.

Flaws in the design and access in and around suburban stations were a key factor in the prevalence and location of attacks.

Promise of 100 affordable new homes influences final go ahead for tower blocks at High Barnet tube station and loss of car parking

Dame Theresa Villiers, formerly MP for Chipping Barnet, who described herself as a resident and passenger, insisted that the loss of the station car park would damage the quality of life of many thousands of Barnet residents.

Anyone with impaired mobility would be at a disadvantage and the suggestion that more people might like to cycle to the station ignored the steepness of Barnet Hill – as she could testify personally it was “a tough climb for cyclists”.

“High Barnet station has been my station for 21 years. It is our get away to the world. Please don’t curtail the freedom of High Barnet people to live our lives the way we want to.”  

Promise of 100 affordable new homes influences final go ahead for tower blocks at High Barnet tube station and loss of car parking

There was one speaker in support of the scheme, High Barnet student Yana Kostova, who said that given the pressure on local housing the only chance was to build upwards.

The prospect of more affordable homes was a relief. She thought High Barnet could “blossom and attract a younger generation with such schemes”.

In response to questions from the deputy mayor, Martin Scholar, head of planning for Places for London, said the developers Barratt Homes had maximised the number of affordable homes at High Barnet Place which would allow more people to get on the housing ladder.

“Forty per cent affordable homes at High Barnet is much higher than for most schemes in London” – a consideration that was given emphasis in the deputy mayor’s final decision.

In a statement issued after the hearing, Dan Tomlinson, MP for Chipping Barnet and Exchequer Secretary to the Treasury, criticised the go ahead for a scheme which was clearly not in line with the local plan.

“Planning decisions aren’t mine to make as the local MP, but Barnet Labour has made it views very clear on these proposals.

“It is in black and white in Barnet’s local plan that seven storeys is the maximum for housing on this site.

“It is not right for the GA to overrule elected councillors to approve a scheme with an 11-storey block that contravenes the plan.”

Mr Tomlinson’s statement was followed by a statement from Barnet Labour Party expressing its opposition to the go-ahead for high storey blocks of flats at High Barnet tube station and GLA approval for the Great North Leisure Park development:

“It is extremely disappointing that two local planning decisions based on the local plan and London plan and with the backing of the local community have been overturned by the GLA.

“Local councillors should be trusted to make decisions based on the best interest of their communities.”

Promise of 100 affordable new homes influences final go ahead for tower blocks at High Barnet tube station and loss of car parking

Posted on — 1 Comment

Black Horse to re-open in mid-June after extensive repairs – but uncertain future for Builders Arms now on the market for £695,000

Black Horse to re-open in mid-June after extensive repairs – but uncertain future for Builders Arms now on the market for £695,000

After the loss of several pubs around High Barnet in recent weeks, work has finally started on major repairs to the Black Horse in Wood Street, and it is due to re-open in mid-June after being closed since last September.

Scaffolding surrounds the building and local residents who feared the worst when metal grilles were installed across the doors and windows are delighted to hear the news.

With the approach of warm weather, they say they can’t wait for the re-opening of the pub’s garden which is popular weekend venue.

Star Pubs told the Barnet Society that additional building work has proved necessary and it will take longer than originally anticipated, but they hope the pub can re-open by mid-June.

A new tenant – described as “a local businessman” – has taken on the tenancy.

To the disappointment of some previous customers, Star Pubs say the Black Horse will not be reverting to a micro-brewery which had operated at the pub in the past and produced its own ales.

Earlier this year, because of concern about the future of the Black Horse, Barnet Council accepted a community request for the pub to be protected by an order declaring the building as asset of community value.

ACV protection allows the community to enter a bid if the pub is sold for redevelopment – protection already provided for three other nearby pubs, the Lord Nelson, Sebright Arms and Ye Olde Monken Holt, as well as the Prince of Wales in East Barnet.

Black Horse public house in Wood Street Barnet to re-open after nine-month closure but now closed Builders Arms in New Barnet for sale at £695,000

A petition has been launched to secure ACV protection for the Builders Arms in Albert Road, New Barnet, which closed in mid-April and is now on the market for £695,000.

A two-year struggle to keep going finally defeated the pub’s landlady who blamed a loss of trade on the disruption caused by ending up in the middle of a massive construction site.

Albert Road is the main access to the site where Fairview Homes are building eleven high-rise blocks of flats to provide 420 new homes, and the pub found itself marooned in the redevelopment.

Despite considerable local support, the landlady reluctantly decided to hand her tenancy back to the brewers Greene King raising local concern about the future of a pub praised by the Campaign for Real Ale.

Former customers and friends started the petition in an attempt to preserve what they say is a “much loved local institution”.

Greene King, which is reported to be planning to sell off 300 of its tenanted and managed pubs, put the Builders Arms on the market soon after it ceased trading in mid-April.

WTS, agents for the sale, say the building does offer the potential for alternative use, subject to planning consent, and the property might appeal to “local licensed operators, developers, builders and investors.”

Another recent pub closure was that of the Hadley House bar and restaurant in Barnet High Street, which in previous years was known as the King George and earlier as the King of Prussia – but another High Street hostelry, the King’s Head, which closed for a month for renovations is due to re-open on June 12.

Posted on — 1 Comment

Facing an uncertain future: unsteady state of Barnet’s iconic whalebones archway – can it be repaired or replaced with a replica?  

Facing an uncertain future: unsteady state of Barnet’s iconic whalebones archway – can it be repaired or replaced with a replica?  

An historic whalebones arch beside Wood Street, High Barnet, has had to be encased in scaffolding after the owners of Whalebones House feared it might collapse and cause an injury to passersby.

Signs of movement in its footings and cracks in the archway – once the jaw bones of a ninety-foot-long blue whale – prompted concern about its safety.

Hill Group, who are building 115 new homes in adjoining fields, installed the scaffolding as a protective measure to safeguard the arch and to preserve “a unique local landmark”.

Facing an uncertain future: unsteady state of Barnet’s iconic whalebones archway – can it be repaired or replaced with a replica?  

Hill’s intervention has been welcomed by the owners of Whalebones House, Patrick Shanahan and Helena Boland, who say urgent action is need to either repair the whalebones or replace them with a replica archway.

Facing an uncertain future: unsteady state of Barnet’s iconic whalebones archway – can it be repaired or replaced with a replica?  

Straps have been applied around the surface to ensure there is no further fragmentation of the structure.

A set of jawbones was first erected as a gateway to Whalebones House in the 1860s or perhaps even earlier.

They were last replaced in 1939 by former owner of the house, Miss Gwyneth Cowing, whose family owned the Barnet Press newspaper.

She paid for two jawbones, each weighing three-quarters of a ton, to be transported to Barnet from Norway where the carcase of the whale, which had been captured in the South Seas, had been dismembered.

It took half a dozen workmen, under the direction of local builders W. Foster & Sons, all day to manoeuvre the gigantic jawbones into place and set them in six feet of concrete.

Cracks in the jawbone on the Arkley side of the drive started appearing at Easter; then its footing became dislodged; and it became clear the archway was in danger of collapsing.

Facing an uncertain future: unsteady state of Barnet’s iconic whalebones archway – can it be repaired or replaced with a replica?  

Mr Shanahan said he first became aware of the damage after heavy equipment being used by the contractors started crossing the driveway less than three metres from the jawbones.

“Excavators and piling equipment kept being moved to and from the main construction area to a smaller site off Wellhouse Lane where there is to be a new community building and studio for the Barnet Guild of Artists.

“Because of the fragile state of the jawbones we have asked the contractors to stop crossing the driveway and generating the kind of vibration which has clearly been having a devastating impact.”    

After alerting the Hill Group to what had happened, the owners of Whalebones House asked for advice from Barnet Council on the historic status of the whalebones and whether permission would be needed to dismantle the archway and install a replacement.

Facing an uncertain future: unsteady state of Barnet’s iconic whalebones archway – can it be repaired or replaced with a replica?  

They hope that the Hill Group and the trustees of the Gwyneth Cowing estate – which sold off the farmland for housing – will contribute to the cost of repairing or replacing the archway.

“Hill are going to call their new housing estate and gardens Whalebone Park, so they have a responsibility to ensure the whalebones remain an integral part of the whole development,” said Mr Shanahan.

“So far we have been unable to gain any assistance from Barnet Council’s planning or heritage departments, and we are anxious to work out how best to safeguard the future of the archway.”

Facing an uncertain future: unsteady state of Barnet’s iconic whalebones archway – can it be repaired or replaced with a replica?  

Whalebones House is a Grade II listed building of special interest and the whalebones at the entrance to the drive are specifically referred to in the appraisal for the Wood Street Conservation area which includes the Whalebones estate.

It says that the whalebones at the entrance sit within “a notable tree boundary and create an entry feature to the space.”

Mr Shanahan says former fishing and whaling communities which have historic whalebone arches, including Whitby in Yorkshire and coastal ports in Scotland, are facing similar challenges over how best to protect them.

“Resin bonding has been used to repair some arches. Others have been replaced with replica arches made from synthetic compounds, steel or even brass.

“We need advice and help in working out how the arch can be preserved or replaced.”

Facing an uncertain future: unsteady state of Barnet’s iconic whalebones archway – can it be repaired or replaced with a replica?  

There are competing theories as to how and why whalebones were first erected in Wood Street.

One report in the Barnet Press suggested the famous polar explorer John Franklin (1786-1847) once lived in Whalebones and according to local thinking installed the first set of whalebones as early as the 1830s.

A week later the paper published an alternative version: Frederick Brown, who lived at 92 Wood Street, said his sister was married to Mr Easton, a Thames waterman, who had lived at the house and started the tradition.

Mr Easton had joined the firm of Smith and Sons, whalebone and sealskin merchants, who plied their trade from the Thames, and he obtained a pair of whalebones which it was thought were erected in the 1860s and gave the house its name.

Records at Barnet Museum suggest the house was built in 1815 and the first reference to it being named Whalebones was on a map dated 1872.

Motorists travelling along Wood Street often miss seeing the jawbones, especially when the trees and hedges are in leaf and much of that side of the road is filled in parked cars.

Pedestrians get a far better view and might like to renew an old Chipping Barnet custom: according to local legal it was good luck to walk under the archway, make a wish or share a kiss.

Over the years countless Barnet youngsters have marvelled at the size of the jaw bones from a blue whale, the largest species captured in the South Seas.

Angela Morris of King’s Road, Barnet, remembers that as a seven-year-old in the 1950s she attended a Brownie pack that met in the barn at Whalebones.

“In those days there were another two sets of whalebones, only much smaller. One was at the gateway to the house and one that had fallen down beside a path that went to the barn where the Brownies met.”

Posted on — 4 Comments

High Court backs approval for two travellers’ caravans in a Mays Lane paddock once used for grazing horses

High Court rejects attempt by Barnet Council to halt the go ahead for a site for two travellers' caravans on a paddock in Mays Lane Green Belt

Barnet Council’s attempt to halt the go ahead for a travellers’ caravan site on a field in Green Belt land off Mays Lane has failed in the High Court to the disappointment of a local residents’ group.

Gina Theodorou, chair of the Quinta Village Green Residents’ Association, said that despite the setback they were determined to continue their fight to protect the Green Belt along Mays Lane.

Failure by the council to secure a full judicial review of a planning inspector’s decision in favour of the travellers site means that work installing hard standing can now go ahead in a two-acre paddock – see above – which was previously used for grazing horses.

Space has been approved for two static caravans, two mobile homes and two day rooms to be occupied by two traveller families.

The application was made by brothers Patrick and J Casey.

A refusal by the council to grant approval led to a lengthy planning inquiry last year when the inspector decided that the “very special circumstances” of the two families outweighed any harm to the Green Belt.

This ruling was challenged by the council on the grounds that the inspector’s conclusion was factually flawed because of his conclusion that a go ahead for the site was in the best interests of the “seven young children” involved.

In its challenge, the council argued that the evidence showed that in fact only four or five children would live on the site.

After a two-hour hearing – which Ms Theodorou attended – the High Court accepted that while there was a factual error in the inspector’s decision it did not materially affect the outcome of whether to allow the site on Green Belt land. Development could now proceed.

“We are disappointed because although this decision affects only one site, it means that once the land is developed it undermines the protection for our local green spaces,” said Ms Theodorou.

“There could now be future proposals for travellers’ sites on Green Belt land on both sides of the paddock and this approval would make it easier to justify.

“But that is how the Green Belt is gradually eroded.

“Our focus now has to be to focus on the bigger picture – to protect what remains of our Green Belt along Mays Lane and to ensure that our local green spaces are managed in a way that benefits both the environment and the community.”   

Posted on — 3 Comments

Leaseholders of The Spires Shopping Centre in administration – Chipping Barnet Town Team seeking full explanation 

Chipping Barnet Town Team are seeking a full explanation given concern about leaseholders of The Spires Shopping Centre in administration.

A renewed attempt is being made to get up to date information on the future ownership of The Spires Shopping Centre in High Barnet following a second intervention by the High Court appointing administrators for companies involved with its leases.

Purchase of The Spires for £28 million in 2021 was made in the name of BYM Capital which went into administration in 2023.

Freehold of The Spires’ site is owned by Barnet Council.

Companies House has now confirmed new administrators have been appointed to take control of NEG The Spires Ltd, named as the holder of the leases.

An associated company NEG Barnet Market Ltd, which owns the freehold of the former site of Barnet Market, is also under the control of the same administrators.

Given the new situation and the possibility, the adjacent sites could now be split up – and the added grave uncertainty about the future of one of the town’s key assets – the Chipping Barnet Town Team is seeking to make contact with the new team of administrators.

“Community groups and other key stakeholders in the town are desperate to find out what is going on,” said town team secretary Eamonn Rafferty.

“We have all been left in the dark for far too long.”

“Bearing in mind the strategic importance to the town of The Spires precinct of shops, the Waitrose supermarket and the multi-storey car park, we think the Town Team must be consulted before any key decisions are taken about their future.

“We want to know more about the options being considered by the administrators. If there is a complicated break-up of the assets it could put the future of the entire shopping centre at risk.”

Barnet Councillor David Longstaff, a member of the Town Team, and the Chipping Barnet MP Dan Tomlinson, have both indicated they will try to gain more information. 

When administrators were first appointed in November 2023, Barnet Council – which owns the freehold of The Spires’ site – insisted that there would be no interruption in the running of the shopping centre.

Operation of the centre and its facilities such as public conveniences – conducted through the management of Savills Property Management – was said to be the responsibility of a separate company which the council had been assured was not in the hands of the administrators and would continue without interruption.

FMX Urban Property Advisers, which took on responsibility in March 2024 for leasing retail units in the shopping centre, told the Barnet Society that it was “business as usual” when it came to seeking for new tenants for vacant outlets.

“Our role as letting agents is not affected” said FMX.

In promotional material, it describes The Spires as a “primary retail destination…boasting an affluent surrounding catchment and benefiting from excellent transport links and a 440-space multi-storey car park”.

FMX said their instructions were to help implement a “dynamic and proactive retail strategy” for The Spires.

Prior to going into administration BYM Capital held discussions with Barnet Council and public consultations about possible redevelopment.

There were proposals – about which nothing further has been heard – to convert the shopping centre into a new retail thoroughfare with blocks of flats and shops below together with more flats above the car park and on the site of the former market.

Currently the market site is a car park operated by Britannia Parking, which also operates the multi-storey at the shopping centre.

Concern over how best to safeguard the future of the shopping centre, prompted the formation of a resident’s “Save The Spires” campaign which handed out leaflets calling on Barnet Council to take active steps to preserve “a safe, quiet and much used” civic space at the heart of High Barnet.

Covered walkways and squares within the shopping centre were an important amenity because they were “free of traffic and deserved to be maintained and kept open to the public”. 

Posted on — 2 Comments

Anger in Arkley over plans for a massive new housing estate attracts tv news team ahead of Barnet Council elections   

Anger in Arkley over plans for a massive new housing estate attracts tv news team ahead of Barnet Council elections   

A controversial plan to build up to 230 houses and an 80-bed care home on a former pig farm at Arkley was featured by ITV News London in a report ahead of May’s council elections about the political arguments surrounding the development of green belt land.

Bugler Homes of Rickmansworth is hoping to take advantage of new guidance allowing house building on “previously developed” sites which can now be deemed to be grey belt land.

Arkley resident Hayley Winton (above) told ITV London political correspondent Simon Harris that if Barnet Council approved the scheme, it would have a “huge impact” on life in the village, increasing its size by 25 per cent.

“Arkley is a small village with low density housing, in the middle of the green belt, and a high-density development of 300 homes doesn’t feel right.”

Anger in Arkley over plans for a massive new housing estate attracts tv news team ahead of Barnet Council elections   

Hayley’s opposition to the scheme was shared by another resident Jyoti Dhanak who said it would be shocking if such a large part of green belt was built on.

“Once the green belt has gone, it has gone, and it cannot be replaced.”

Anger in Arkley over plans for a massive new housing estate attracts tv news team ahead of Barnet Council elections   

Because access to the site had been refused, camera operator Gemma Green used a drone to film the 17-acre former pig farm, which is off Rowley Lane, Arkley, and is in the middle of scrubland and woods bordered by the A1 Barnet by-pass.

Anger in Arkley over plans for a massive new housing estate attracts tv news team ahead of Barnet Council elections   

In its “initial vision” for the development, Bugler Homes has applied to the council to discuss plans to build 230 homes, with 50 per cent affordable housing; an 80-bed care home; publicly accessible green spaces and allotments; and improved public right of way footpaths.

Anger in Arkley over plans for a massive new housing estate attracts tv news team ahead of Barnet Council elections   

Robin Bishop (above) who leads for the Barnet Society on planning and the environment, told Simon Harris the development would represent a “substantial erosion” of the green belt which had separated Barnet and Arkley from Borehamwood for the last 80 years.

The fields and woodland around Arkley are included in plans to create a new regional park which is included in Barnet Council’s latest local plan.

“If this development were to be approved it would be a major breach of the proposed regional park.

“A new regional park is a much welcome proposal. It would help to create a comprehensively managed area like the Lea Valley regional park.”

Anger in Arkley over plans for a massive new housing estate attracts tv news team ahead of Barnet Council elections   

Mr Bishop urged planning authorities to proceed with care before allowing development in what housebuilders claimed was now the grey belt.

“If councils give permission for every derelict site in the green belt much of the new housing will be highly unsuitable, in places where people will not be close to amenities or public transport.”

The Rowley Lane pig farm site is part of a triangle of land which is bounded by Barnet Road, Barnet by-pass and Rowley Lane.

Anger in Arkley over plans for a massive new housing estate attracts tv news team ahead of Barnet Council elections   

The illustration above shows how the land — to the east of the by-pass — has been parcelled into different plots.

Online research has revealed that 148 acres of land within this area – almost all of which is green belt – is owned by housebuilders and other associated companies and could provide space for up to 1,200 new homes.

If planning permission for housing could be obtained the land would be worth over £150 million.

One housebuilder owns 25 acres, with potential for 192 houses, on a site worth £39 million; another has 22 acres, with room for 285 homes, on a site worth £43 million.

Robin Bishop said the revelation that so much of the green belt land to the north of Arkley is effectively a land bank for housebuilders only serves to highlight the looming scandal over the likely approval of grey belt land for housing and other needs.

“There seems every likelihood that unlocking grey belt land for development will result in windfall profits for developers who have wilfully neglected land which they have been sitting on for years.

ITV News London to feature controversial plan for massive new housing estate in Arkley as part of report into political row over green belt land ahead of council elections.

Close to the pig farm site there has been unauthorised clearance of woodland in what had been declared a site of importance for nature conservation.

Hayley Winton said Arkley residents had been appalled when they saw a bulldozer hacking away at mature trees and levelling an acre of the woodland.

“Apparently the land has been sold as three plots for housing but there is no planning permission.

“We reported what happened to Barnet Council who say this is one of the worst cases they have ever seen of destruction of protected trees.

“We were told there will be consequences but how do you replace woodland like this which is in the green belt and was supposed to have special protection.”

Posted on — 3 Comments

Government and developers set their sights on the Green Belt

View of Green Belt south of Potters Bar showing green fields, trees and hedges with M25 in background

This swathe of Green Belt (above) will be mostly built over if current plans are approved. And within Barnet, dozens of so-called ‘Grey Belt’ sites are being targetted for new homes (few of which are likely to be affordable). The Labour Council promises to create a Regional Park, which could prevent that. This should be an issue in our local election in May – but do voters know or care?

Between Potters Bar and Borehamwood, several enormous data centres have already been approved on land in the foreground of the photo above. Beyond the M25 will be a major expansion of Sky studios. For land off to the left of the photo, a planning application for 900 new homes has been refused by Hertsmere Council, but the developer has appealed against the decision.

Crews Hill & Chase Park new town

Between Barnet and Enfield, the government proposes a new town of 21,000 homes on Green Belt land. The plans are supported by Enfield Council and the Mayor of London but opposed by the Enfield Society and Enfield RoadWatch.

Government and developers set their sights on the Green Belt

The Barnet Society has objected to any loss of the green buffer that exists between Barnet and Enfield. It is vital to preserve the separate identities of settlements that would otherwise merge into amorphous suburbia, and a vital reservoir of biodiversity.

Just ahead of the local elections in May, groups and communities across the UK will be taking part in a UK-wide Day of Action for Nature, Parks and Green Spaces on Saturday 18 April. Its purpose is to demonstrate, visibly and collectively, that people everywhere care deeply about the natural world and want to see it protected and restored. Join the national day of action here.

Government and developers set their sights on the Green Belt

Barnet’s Green Belt

Government and developers set their sights on the Green Belt

The countryside on three sides of Chipping (or High) Barnet was saved in 1945 from housing development, largely by the efforts of the Barnet Society. In 1955 it was formally designated part of the London Metropolitan Green Belt. The map above shows how well it has survived – at least until now.

For decades developers have tried to build in it. So far, our Council has effectively prevented most new development. Exceptions have generally been restricted to replacement of obsolescent farm buildings.

Lately, however, we’ve seen an increase in speculative purchases of, and planning applications for, Green Belt land. Also notable has been unsightly and apparently deliberate neglect of existing buildings and landscape. The prospect of profiting from escalating land values and house prices beats the cost of maintaining or restoring property.

Expectations have been fuelled by the housing crisis, which has driven up mortgages and rents. And building costs have soared due to Brexit, Covid-19, wars in Ukraine and the Middle East and the higher safety standards introduced since the Grenfell Tower tragedy. Building on city brownfield sites has become less financially viable. No wonder the Green Belt, where building is cheaper, has become so appealing to developers and politicians.

And Labour politicians have opened the door to its development.

Grey Belt sites

In 2024, Sir Keir Starmer promised to release low-quality or neglected Green Belt land for housebuilding. In 2025, the National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF) was revised to allow housing development on Grey Belt sites subject to ‘Golden Rules’. And public consultation recently closed on further relaxations of the NPPF.

The consequence has been a flood of planning applications for allegedly Grey sites. In December 2025 CPRE, the countryside charity, reported new research revealing that the Grey Belt policy is enabling large-scale development on England’s unspoilt rural landscapes – not, as ministers promised, on unused car parks and derelict petrol stations.

Since December 2024, when the policy was introduced, 13 developments of 10 or more homes have been approved by government Planning Inspectors on Grey land in the Green Belt. The approvals have been granted over the heads of local councils. Of the 1,250 homes these schemes will deliver, 88% will be built on previously undeveloped countryside.

In Barnet, it’s becoming routine for prospective developers of Green Belt land to describe their sites as Grey. Although some sites are quite small, they’re dotted around and have a disproportionately harmful impact on the countryside. Most aren’t served by public transport and won’t be developed for affordable (let alone social) housing. A selection is illustrated below.

Government and developers set their sights on the Green Belt

Barnet Regional Park

Barnet Labour Party’s local election leaflet contains this pledge:

“We will… create a ‘Regional Park’ in the green belt.”

It would be centred on the astonishingly intact and peaceful fields and woods between Arkley and Mill Hill (below).

Government and developers set their sights on the Green Belt

The concept is already embedded in Barnet’s Local Plan (adopted by the Council last year) where Policy GSS13 states,

“The Council supports the creation of a new Regional Park within designated Green Belt or Metropolitan Open Land in the Brent Valley and Barnet Plateau Green Grid Area…”

Inspired in part by the success of the Lea Valley Regional Park, interventions would include “the enhancement of footpath, cycling and bridleway networks; improved green corridors and nature conservation areas [and] a network of new strategic recreational destinations.”

The map below (from the Council’s 2019 Growth Strategy) shows its intended configuration.

Government and developers set their sights on the Green Belt

Most importantly – since the Regional Park contains several of the Grey sites illustrated above – designation should provide stronger protection from inappropriate development. It would bring better public awareness and funding to ensure high design standards and long-term management of the area.

An imaginative suggestion from Roger Chapman of Barnet Green Spaces Network is for a regional food and biodiversity park to encourage a wide range of food growing practices. Linked with primary, secondary and post-16 education institutions and forest schools, it would provide an inspiring setting for environmental education and pathways to vocational qualifications in horticulture, animal husbandry and other skills essential for future food security.

As Roger says, “The park would build upon Barnet’s extensive agricultural history and heritage, enabling old stories to be retold and new ones to be created.” That’s an idea worth voting for.

The need for proper planning

Debate about the Green Belt is hampered by the lack of any regional strategy. There has been no planning body for the South-East for decades. Responsibility for the Green Belt is split between dozens of Local Planning Authorities.

The Mayor of London launched a London-wide review of the Green Belt to identify Grey Belt land for housing to tackle London’s housing crisis, but it is limited to the Greater London area. It was expected to be completed by the end of 2025 but is still awaited.

As a consequence every planning application in the Green (or Grey) Belt, however minor, becomes a bitter battle between developers, planners and residents.

The creation of the Green Belt was made possible by the government’s adoption of Patrick Abercrombie’s Greater London Plan, which created a ring of new towns around London, outside the Green Belt, to absorb the demand for new housing and promote alternative centres of growth. If we had a vision as sensible and comprehensive as that for our society – and for the natural world with which we co-exist – surely most of us would accept development in the most sustainable (or least harmful) locations in exchange for guaranteed long-term protection of our most beautiful and biodiverse environments.

Crews Hill & Chase Park new town and Barnet Regional Park could be examples of such an approach. As yet details of both projects are far too hazy for a final public decision. But each could transform substantial sectors of their borough. Whether to proceed with project planning, feasibility studies and technical investigations ought to be a matter of great public interest. This coming election is an opportunity to test the popularity of both projects.

Posted on — 7 Comments

Final days at Builders Arms, New Barnet, as customers sign a petition to get asset of community value order to safeguard pub’s future  

Final days at Builders Arms, New Barnet, as customers sign a petition to get asset of community value order to safeguard pub’s future  

A two-year struggle to keep going amid the disruption caused by ending up in the middle of a construction site has finally defeated the landlady of the aptly named Builders Arms in New Barnet.

She has reluctantly decided to hand her tenancy back to the brewers Greene King raising local concern about the future of a pub praised by the Campaign for Real Ale.

A petition has been launched by customers and friends to preserve what they say is a “much loved local institution”.

The aim of the petition organisers, Danielle Holiday and Nikki Hill, is to secure the registration of the Builders Arms as an asset of community value with Barnet Council while exploring other possible business models for the pub.

East Barnet’s councillors – Phil Cohen, Edith David and Simon Radford – have all signed the petition and are promising their support in the bid to safeguard the pub’s future by gaining ACV status.

Landlady Silva told the Barnet Society that once construction work started in 2024 on the massive housing development on the site of the former New Barnet gas works customers found it increasingly difficult to reach the pub.

Final days at Builders Arms, New Barnet, as customers sign a petition to get asset of community value order to safeguard pub’s future  

Albert Road is the is the main access to the site where Fairview Homes are building eleven high-rise blocks of flats to provide 420 new homes – and a street view shows how the pub is dwarfed the scale of the redevelopment.

Initially Albert Road was blocked regularly by lorries delivering materials and construction equipment and, because of the hindrance and possible danger to customers, the Builders Arms had to cease opening at lunch times.

“Since then, access to the pub hasn’t improved and it has been a real struggle financially. It has just proved too much.”

Silva, who took on the Builders Arms eight years ago, said that she could not hang on for another year or two until the completion of the new development when all the flats might be fully occupied.

“You simply cannot run a pub when it is in the middle of a construction site. It is so off putting for customers. We can’t survive, so our tenancy ends on Sunday 12 April.

“At present there is no through road and no parking but let’s hope that Greene King can re-open one day.”

Once news broke two weeks ago that the pub was to close there has been an emotional response on the Builders Arm’s Facebook page with an appeal to regular customers to celebrate the “happy times, the music, and the unforgettable nights” they had all enjoyed.

With the pub having to be cleared of furniture, signs and fixtures, customers were invited to raise a glass and perhaps “even take home a little piece of the Builders Arms, something that might be a treasure for you.”

CAMRA has backed the Builders Arms as a real ale pub since 1970, and it has built up considerable loyalty over the

decades.

Final days at Builders Arms, New Barnet, as customers sign a petition to get asset of community value order to safeguard pub’s future  

Connie East (see above) said that serving behind the bar was a real privilege because the Builders Arms had always been part of her family.

“I was brought here first as a baby 24 years ago as my parents were regulars. It has always been a real family pub.”

Dannielle Holiday, who helped organise the petition, has an even stronger family connection.

Her grandfather was a customer, so were her parents, and her own grown-up children have followed the tradition.

“The Builders Arms is a living testament to the rich local history of New Barnet,” said Danielle.

“Hundreds of local residents are signing up and joining our effort to preserve a much-cherished local pub.”

Petition launch to get asset of community value order on Builders Arms, New Barnet, becuase of pub's closure due to construction disruption during massive housing development.

When the Barnet Society first reported on the plight of the Builders Arms in 2024 the assistant manager Nina Hristova – see above – looked on in despair as work was progressing on a block of flats immediately opposite the pub.

At the time East Barnet councillor Simon Radford and Chipping Barnet MP Dan Tomlinson intervened after the pub’s staff appealed for help in curbing the mayhem and keeping the highway clear of work.

Councillor Radford said he and councillors Cohen and David had built up considerable expertise in using the asset of community value process to safeguard threatened pubs – and exercise which had proved highly successful when campaigning for the re-opening of Prince of Wales, the only pub in East Barnet village.

“As councillors we would like to pay tribute to Silva, George, Nina and the rest of the team who have run the Builders Arms for so many years, making it truly a community asset despite such outsized challenges to the business,” said councillor Radford.

“We owe them a debt of gratitude for what they have achieved with the pub, and we would also like to thank Daniella and Nikki for leading from the front in trying to save the pub.”

Councillor David said she hoped the community would show what the pub meant to them by signing the petition.

“We can all demonstrate our links with the Builders Arms through family stories and how the pub has been there for us on special occasions. The fight to save the Builders Arms goes on.”