Posted on — 1 Comment

Goodbye to (nearly) all this…

Goodbye to (nearly) all this…

Above is the Green Belt north of the M25 with St Albans in the distance. Hertsmere Borough Council proposes to build a new 5,000-home township, Bowmans Cross, on much of this land. It’s just one of many developments close to Barnet in Hertsmere’s draft Local Plan for 2026-41. You have until 17th November to submit your views on the planning application for Bowmans Cross, and until the 19th on the Local Plan.

…And hello to this?

Goodbye to (nearly) all this…

Above: Bowmans Cross looking S-W – visualisation by HTA Design LLP

Hertsmere’s Local Plan

About 79% of the area of Barnet’s northern neighbour, Hertsmere, is currently designated as Metropolitan Green Belt. Five years ago Hertsmere published a draft Local Plan that proposed to build over 10% of it – including a substantial chunk of the pleasant countryside that separates Barnet from Borehamwood and Potters Bar. The Barnet Society and some 20,000 others objected. In January 2022 Hertsmere scrapped that Plan.

Now a new (Regulation 19) Plan is out for consultation, but it’s not very different from the previous version. Its Policy H9.C states,

“Speculative proposals for major-scale housing development upon sites in Hertsmere’s countryside/Green Belt beyond the Borough’s four main towns [Borehamwood, Bushey, Potters Bar & Radlett] will not be positively considered…”

But in practice the Plan pushes the boundaries of Borehamwood and Potters Bar in our direction. These are the new developments that we will notice most:

  • 392 houses south of Borehamwood.
  • Expansion of the Sky studios site north-eastwards from Borehamwood.
  • Three data centres between South Mimms and Potters Bar.
  • 1,292 houses on fields south of Potters Bar.
  • A new employment site south-east of M25 Junction 24.

Development of the fields separating Potters Bar from the M25 will be particularly destructive. Not only do they provide an attractive working agricultural landscape between Potters Bar and Barnet, they link visually with Bentley Heath, Dancers Hill, Wrotham Park and Dyrham Park to create a green panorama much greater than the sum of its parts.

Goodbye to (nearly) all this…

Add to those the new township of Bowmans Cross, and 720 hectares of Green Belt will be lost – an area ten times the size of Hadley Common and Hadley Wood combined.

Another major concern of ours is that little is said about transport improvements, which will be vital to the Plan’s success, especially in Hertsmere’s more rural areas. Barnet already suffers from road and parking congestion due to commuting from Hertfordshire into London, and our bus link with Potters Bar is frail. Building new homes and workplaces near our border seems certain to exacerbate these strains.

It’s also disappointing that although the Plan extols the value of nature and promises green corridors and enhanced pedestrian and cycle routes in towns and new developments, there are no plans for new rural routes of any kind.

We also regret that safeguarding of the cross-border Watling Chase Community Forest is so fleetingly mentioned in the Plan, and its expansion not at all.

Better news for Barnet is that no new building is planned in the countryside south of the M25 and east of the A1. Some of our residents will find work in Hertsmere’s media and IT industries. And new homes near Barnet are likely to be cheaper and more spacious than in Barnet itself. They’ll attract young couples and families who can’t afford property in our borough. It would be ironic if Hertsmere’s new housing ended up benefitting struggling Barnet residents at the expense of its own.

The deadline for representations on the draft Local Plan is 11:59pm on Thursday 19 November.

You can read the relevant documents and guidance here:

You can submit your representation here:

Goodbye to (nearly) all this…

Above: Bowmans Cross looking S-E – visualisation by HTA Design LLP

Bowmans Cross

This will be a new township on open fields and obsolescent sand and gravel quarries by the M25 north of North Mymms. A first phase of 2,500 homes will be built by 2041, growing ultimately to 5,000 homes. Population figures aren’t given, but presumably will eventually total at least 15,000.

There’s clearly something to be said for concentrating new homes in a few places large enough to support a decent range of services such as schools, clinics, retail and social facilities, rather than sprinkling them across our countryside where few services will be viable and residents will depend on cars. A sustainably planned community could also offer great opportunities for recycling and energy generation.

But although the application drawings show lots of greenery, the applicant makes no firm commitment to achieving exemplary environmental standards, only “a holistic view of sustainability, supporting the journey to net zero” (whatever that means). The new homes will only be net zero “where viable” – a big “if”. A site-wide heat network is also “not currently considered to be viable”. A number of further energy efficiency measures “will be considered” but are not guaranteed.

Another fundamental weakness of the scheme is transport. Although Bowmans Cross adjoins the M25, that’s already unacceptably congested at peak times. It has no railway station, nor any plans for a rapid transit system. The application promises new bus services, but the only new route specified at the start of occupation is a shuttle 85 bus to and from Potters Bar station, though eventually this will be replaced by an 86 bus and extended to Hatfield. Four mobility hubs (integrated EV charging, car club, cycle/scooter hire and related facilities) are shown, but in reality most residents seem likely to keep their own cars.

This application looks like a lost opportunity. Last year the government’s New Towns taskforce stated,

“We want exemplary development to be the norm, not the exception. The next generation of new towns must be well-connected, well-designed, sustainable, healthy and attractive places where people want to live and have all the infrastructure, amenities and services necessary to sustain thriving communities established from the outset.” 

Measured against those principles, it is hard to see this planning application as offering much more than a pretty dormitory estate.

The deadline for comments on the Bowmans Cross planning application is 11:59pm on Tuesday 17 November.

You can submit your comments here. The application reference no. is 26/1330/OUTEI.

Posted on — 3 Comments

Goodbye to our Green Belt?

Goodbye to our Green Belt?

Above is the Green Belt between Barnet and St Albans. It’s the site of Bowmans Cross, a new settlement planned by Hertsmere Council. It will eventually have 6,000 homes for around 15,000 people – nearly as many as live in High Barnet ward. It will be a net-zero carbon, self-sustaining community, and the sketch above shows lots of trees. But if Hertsmere’s draft Local Plan is accepted, over 10% of Hertsmere’s (and also effectively Barnet’s) Green Belt will be lost forever.

Bowmans Cross is a showpiece of the Plan, which is currently out for public consultation. Another is a 63-hectare Media Quarter east of Borehamwood, which it is hoped will provide thousands of jobs. Other proposals include 2,770 houses in and around Borehamwood, 900 on the fields south of Potters Bar and 225 at South Mimms village (to list only those close to Barnet).

Good news for Barnet is that no new building is planned for the countryside south of the M25 and east of the A1. The media work opportunities will be welcome, to Barnet as much as to Hertsmere residents. But the Plan is vague about crucial details, and there’s much to cause concern:

  • Well over 10% of Hertsmere’s Green Belt will be built over.
  • At the low housing densities proposed, few homes are likely to be affordable.
  • About half of the new housing is to be built on brownfield land, but the proportion ought to be higher.
  • Little information is provided about Bowmans Cross, a new town half the size of Borehamwood and seven-tenths that of Potters Bar.
  • The economic case for a massive Media Quarter, or its long-term viability in a distributed digital age, is unexplained.
  • How Hertsmere residents will be prioritised for either housing or jobs isn’t stated.
  • Very little is said about transport, which will be vital to the Plan’s success, especially in semi-rural areas.
  • There is a potentially serious conflict with Enfield’s Local Plan over land use around M25 Junction 24.

We sympathise with Hertsmere’s predicament. It has to meet an ambitious government housing target, yet 79% of its area is designated as Metropolitan Green Belt, where development is only justifiable under very exceptional circumstances. But how hard has Hertsmere’s looked at its housing need and re-use of its brownfield land?

Its housing target is for a minimum of 760 new homes a year, or at least 12,160 homes by 2038. That’s based on the South West Herts Local Housing Needs Assessment, which appears not to have been challenged. Those who’ve been following the U-turns in the government’s proposed planning reforms will wonder how robust such figures are. The results of the 2021 Census are urgently needed to substantiate predictions of continuing population growth in the South-East, post-Brexit and post-Covid.

There’s also the question of whether Hertsmere’s houses will meet its own needs. It’s not explained how existing local residents will be prioritised. New homes near Barnet are almost certain to be cheaper and more spacious, internally and externally, than in Barnet itself. They’re bound to attract young couples and families struggling to afford property in our area. It would be ironic if much of Hertsmere’s new housing ended up benefitting Londoners at the expense of its own residents.

A further doubt surrounds affordability. The Plan says that 35% of new homes will be affordable, but CPRE research shows that only a tenth of homes built in the Green Belt are affordable, and these are rarely for social rent.

The Plan says, “The strategic green belt will be protected…and improvements made to the countryside and biodiversity to offset the impact of development.” That glosses over the fact that at least 10% of Hertsmere’s present Green Belt will be sacrificed to the developments listed above. Across the borough, the total will be greater, but the Plan is silent about the figure.

It‘s unclear how rigorously Hertsmere has investigated the alternative of re-using brownfield land. Table 3 in the Plan claims that 6,020 new homes – nearly half of its 15-year total requirement – would be on urban sites. According to its Table 2, 2,765 of such sites are available excluding smaller villages/hamlets, which seems scarcely credible. If true, it’s good news, but no brownfield register is mentioned to substantiate it.

If that brownfield land were to be redeveloped at densities equivalent to, say, the award-winning Newhall in Harlow – i.e. no more than four stories high, at 22 dwellings per hectare – even more of Hertsmere’s housing need could be met without resorting to Green Belt land. Alternatively, doubling the density currently proposed for Bowmans Cross (under 10 dwellings per hectare) would have a similar beneficial effect.

For Barnet residents, 900 homes on Green Belt separating Potters Bar from the M25 will be saddening. Not only do the present fields provide an attractive working agricultural landscape between Potters Bar and Barnet, they link visually with Bentley Heath, Dancers Hill, Wrotham Park, Dyrham Park and other greenery to create a panorama that’s much greater than the sum of its parts. The Baker Street and Barnet Road motorway bridges will make dismal southern gateways to the new housing, and it’s hard to imagine a pleasant life in the shadow of the M25.

Goodbye to our Green Belt?

For Hertsmere residents – and for Hertsmere Council – all this should be even more worrying. The London Green Belt Council’s report earlier this year ‘Safe Under Us’? revealed that 233,276 homes have already been given, or are seeking, planning permission in the Metropolitan Green Belt. Such has been local concern that several councils have been voted out of office or lost overall control, and the government has lost its parliamentary seat at Chesham & Amersham.

Another weakness of the planning process is illustrated by a potentially serious conflict with Enfield Council’s draft Local Plan. Hertsmere is designating land south-east of Junction 24 for wildlife. But Enfield’s Strategic Policy SP E1 allocates 11 hectares close by for industrial use. Furthermore, Enfield casually mentions that it would “seek to deliver the redevelopment of the wider site (in LB Hertsmere) to provide a coordinated employment offer”. This would detrimentally impact not only wildlife but also existing and proposed residents of Potters Bar.

 

Goodbye to our Green Belt?

The Media Quarter needs critical scrutiny. It will be vast – 63 hectares – and will have 34 sound stages, many times more than currently exist in Elstree & Borehamwood. The future for TV and film may look bright today, but for how long will digital industries continue to rely on centralised production? Unless the Mass Rapid Transport system tantalisingly mentioned in the Plan comes to pass, moreover, access will depend largely on two motorways, one of them notorious for traffic jams.

Transport is a major weakness of this and most of the Plan’s proposed developments. CPRE research shows that people living in Green Belt developments are tied to owning and using cars, as well as being stuck with the cost of commuting, creating further financial stress for families on low incomes. Hertsmere already suffers from poor public transport to and from its outlying estates and villages, but travel occupies only 10 out of 245 pages in its Plan.

A couple of final points from a neighbourly perspective. Firstly, Barnet already suffers from road and parking congestion caused at least partly by the rising number of commuters from Hertfordshire into London. Building new homes and workplaces near our border seems certain to exacerbate that.

Second and lastly, our Society was founded in 1945 specifically to protect the countryside around Chipping Barnet. In 1947-8, our then Treasurer E.H.Lucas researched and wrote Rambles Round Barnet & Rambles in South Hertfordshire, both of which were published by the Barnet Society. The majority of the walks follow public footpaths in Hertsmere, and have benefitted from its careful stewardship. Several generations of Barnet residents have learned to love countryside that is now planned for development. The footpaths may be safeguarded, but without their green environment they will offer a tragically diminished experience.

Goodbye to our Green Belt?

If residents of either Hertsmere or Barnet object to the draft Plan, it’s vital for them to do so by 6 December; after then, no changes of substance will be possible.

Hertsmere’s draft Local Plan can be found at:

https://www.hertsmerelocalplan.com/site/homePage

The deadline for public comments on it is 5pm on Monday 6 December.

The Barnet Society will be submitting a response, but you can also do so yourself as follows by:

  • completing an online survey under the Have Your Say tab on the plan’s bespoke website here
  • submitting comments via the consultation portal also available on the website
  • emailing local.plan@hertsmere.gov.uk
  • writing to Local Plan Consultation, Hertsmere Borough Council, Elstree Way, Borehamwood WD6 9SR.

 

Posted on — 1 Comment

Rambles round Barnet – enjoy them while you can!

Rambles round Barnet – enjoy them while you can!

Chipping Barnet is a great base for some glorious countryside walks, and the best are described in Rambles Round Barnet – two volumes published by the Barnet Society. The good news is that Volume I has just been reprinted in a limited edition. The bad news is that some of the walks are threatened by development, so walk them while you can.

Rambles Round Barnet – In the footsteps of EH Lucas was published by the Barnet Society in 2012 and has been out of print. It was a handy A5 booklet containing four walks from a guidebook originally researched by EH Lucas, the Society’s Treasurer (1948-70), and issued by the Society in 1948.

In 2013 a further three walks from Lucas’s guide were published in Volume II, which is still in print and available from Waterstones in The Spires or directly from the Society.

One of the few benefits of Covid-19 has been revival of interest in the countryside, with a noticeable increase in walkers and cyclists on local paths in the last year. At the conclusion of the Society’s 75th anniversary year, it seemed appropriate to reprint Volume 1.

The reprint is a facsimile, in a limited edition of 150, of the 2012 booklet. No attempt has been made to alter the charming text and illustrations of the 2012 edition, which was largely the work of Owen Jones and David Ely, but eight pages of updates and additional information have been inserted as a postscript. Both Rambles I & II are on sale from Waterstones in The Spires and Barnet Museum, or direct from the Society at £6 per volume (or £10 for both) plus postage and packing. Contact details are given below.

No-one would claim that Barnet and Hertfordshire can compete with more dramatic landscapes elsewhere in Britain. But their quiet qualities often get overlooked, and Covid-19 has reminded many of us how valuable they are. Rambles may not be up there with Guide to the Lakeland Fells, Alfred Wainwright’s famous walking guidebooks to the Lake District. But they are full of shrewd observations and good advice. Lucas, Jones and Ely are Barnet’s Wainwright, and deserve to be celebrated.

Rambles round Barnet – enjoy them while you can!

The four walks described in Rambles Round Barnet – In the footsteps of EH Lucas are:

Walk 1 – The green heart of Barnet  This takes you through countryside that was threatened, in 1945, by Barnet Council’s plans to triple the population of Chipping Barnet to 60,000. The Barnet Society was founded to fight them, and did so successfully.

Walk 2 – Mimmsy meadows and bluebell woods  Between South Mimms and North Mymms (sic) is a beautiful circuit of sequestered woods, open meadows and long views – amazingly, never more than about half a mile from the M25 or A1.

Walk 3 – Ancient fields and a magic grove only half a mile from built-up Barnet  This walk includes two delightful tracts of countryside, one each side of the A1, and an enchanted grove, half a mile long, of venerable trees bordering Dyrham Park.

Walk 4 – Traditional farmland meets modern motorway  Not a walk for those seeking respite from the 21st century, though it has sweet rustic moments. But if you wonder whether English countryside can coexist with modern technology, this is the place to find out.

The walks have all been checked this spring. As well as containing additional information, the insert picks out highlights, lists any changes since 2012, and gives tips on routes and good times to go.

All the walks take you through countryside designated as Green Belt after the 2nd World War, partly due to the campaigning of the Society. With a few exceptions, development is permitted only in very special circumstances. But that hasn’t stopped many applications being submitted. That the landscape has survived largely unspoiled for 75 years is testimony to ongoing work by us and other voluntary groups in Barnet and Hertfordshire, as well as the stewardship of both councils.

Rambles round Barnet – enjoy them while you can!

However, this reprint is tinged with concern that some of the walks will be lost within a few years. Although the UK government and Barnet Council claim to be committed to retaining the Green Belt, and the walks themselves are mostly safeguarded Rights of Way, major developments are currently being planned on or near land over which they pass.

Most of the open land north of the M25 and both sides of the A1 has been identified in Hertsmere Council’s draft Local Plan for potential housing and employment development, as well as pockets south of the M25. Huge Sky and Hertswood film studio complexes are proposed for fields south of Rowley Lane. New Rabley and Redwell ‘Garden Villages’ are proposed near South Mimms. These will all leave a massive mark on what is at present open greenery.

Nor is Barnet Council exempt. Although it plans to create a major new Regional Park between Arkley, Mill Hill and the A1, it also proposes to build an £11m community and leisure hub in the middle of Barnet Playing Fields – which the Council itself has designated Green Belt.

This web post is therefore not simply an invitation to buy Rambles Round Barnet – Volume I while stocks last. It also urges you to get out and savour our wonderful countryside while it is still there to enjoy.

Rambles round Barnet – enjoy them while you can!

Posted on — 6 Comments

Earthworks remodelling Barnet golf course

Diggers at work at the Old Ford Manor Golf Club, but are planning conditions being observed?

Earthworks remodelling Barnet golf course For some weeks past a constant stream of tipper lorries has been unloading top-soil and sub-soil at the northern end of the Old Fold Manor Golf Club, Hadley Green, where extensive landscaping of the golf course is about to start.

Continue reading Earthworks remodelling Barnet golf course

Posted on — 6 Comments

Building Threat on Potters Bar & South Mimms Green Belt

Hertsmere Council is consulting on the possibility of building up to 2,620 new homes

Hertsmere Council is consulting on the possibility of building up to 2,620 new homes plus new places of work between Wrotham Park and Potters Bar, westwards as far as South Mimms and eastwards beyond M25 junction 24. This would have a huge impact on our Green Belt.

Continue reading Building Threat on Potters Bar & South Mimms Green Belt

Posted on — 1 Comment

New finds may throw light on Barnet’s history

Barnet Society’s President Aubrey Rose (left) welcomes Simon Marsh, research officer of the Battlefields Trust, Theresa Villiers, MP, and Howard Simmons, also of the Trust, who is advising Barnet Museum

When work starts in October on a survey and excavation to find the site of the Battle of Barnet of 1471, local residents and schoolchildren will have their chance to play a part in the great upsurge in interest in medieval history that has occurred since the discovery of King Richard III’s remains in a Leicester car park.

Continue reading New finds may throw light on Barnet’s history

Posted on — 4 Comments

Parking claims another casualty

Hadley Hounds latest victim of parking fiasco

High Barnet’s “impossible” parking controls are forcing another independent trader out of the High Street.

Continue reading Parking claims another casualty