Uncertainty over future political control of Barnet Council to continue until critical meeting where the mayor’s vote could be decisive

After a split election result, future political control of Barnet Council will hang in the balance until the newly elected councillors meet for the first time at Hendon Town Hall on Tuesday 19 May.

Labour and Conservatives each gained 31 seats – with one seat going to the Greens – leaving no party in overall control of the council.

A final decision on whether Labour Councillor Barry Rawlings might remain leader of the council or whether the position goes to the Conservative party leader Peter Zinkin could rest on a casting vote by the new Mayor of Barnet.

Discussions have been taking place between party leaders and the council’s chief executive Cath Shaw to agree a procedure to determine the future political control of the council.

In a statement issued immediately after the election, Ms Shaw said it would be for the new councillors to decide how the council should be governed.

In the meantime, residents could be assured they would continue to receive council services as usual.

When they meet on 19 May, the first task of the new council will be to appoint a new Mayor of Barnet to succeed the outgoing mayor, Labour Councillor Danny Rich (who was re-elected in West Finchley).

The new Mayor was expected to have been East Barnet Labour Councillor Edith David, but she lost her seat in the council elections.

If Labour put forward a fresh nomination for mayor – and if that Labour nominee is elected (a decision on which the current mayor has a casting vote) – control of the council could possibly remain in Labour hands.

A new Labour mayor would have a casting vote for the next decision which is to appoint a council leader who would have the task of forming a new administration and appointing a new cabinet.

This is a scenario which could result in Councillor Rawlings continuing as council leader, but it would undoubtedly be opposed by the Conservatives and depends on what happens at the meeting.

An added complication is that given the tied election result, there would need to be a full attendance by both Labour and Conservative councillors. 

If there were absences on either side due to ill health or unexpected circumstances the votes on 19 May might still go either way, hence the continuing uncertainty as to the outcome.

In the council elections, Labour lost ten seats and the Conservatives gained nine resulting in each securing 31 seats with no overall control.

In his statement re-acting to the election result, the Chipping Barnet Labour MP Dan Tomlinson congratulated all the candidates elected for seats in his constituency.

“I look forward to working with you all in the coming years,” said Mr Tomlinson.

“We now have a unique election result – the council is now a balanced hung council.”