Posted on

The Spires developers must up their design game – and drop their building heights

The Spires developers must up their design game – and drop their building heights

The Barnet Society’s Planning & Environment Committee has studied closely the latest design proposals exhibited at The Spires on 12 & 15 April. This is a once-in-a-generation chance to revitalise our town centre, but it risks being wasted.

Frankly, we’re disappointed. Back in December last year, we responded to the initial proposals for The Spires with numerous constructive suggestions and cautionary comments. Over three months later, few of them seem to have been regarded.

The Society’s fundamental position is that we could accept around 250 flats if the result would be a real improvement on the present Spires. That would include a wider range of retail and other uses, a more attractive place to shop and hang out, and better bus/car drop-off and pick-up arrangements (amongst other things).

Unfortunately, the current scheme doesn’t seem to offer such improvements. Benefits to the public realm are at best vague or limited, and in some cases the proposals would be detrimental. Basic information on the new homes, transport, sustainability and the visual impact on neighbours and conservation areas is lacking, but is essential if the developers are to get community support.

We’ve told them our reasons for disappointment – and if you care for the future of our town, please submit your own comments. There’s no deadline, but the sooner you do so the better. You can view the exhibition boards here. Then

The Society has four particular concerns:

Building height

The proposed 5 & 6-storey blocks along the south side of Spires Walk would overshadow the precinct to a completely unacceptable degree. We are also very concerned about the visual impact of the 4, 5 & 6 storeys proposed north of the Spires Walk, on the multi-storey car park and behind Chipping Close, and would have to see verified visualisations from key view-points before commenting further.

Transport

No attempt has been made to improve the present unsatisfactory – and sometimes hazardous – arrangements for buses, car drop-off or pick-up and pedestrian crossing. The scheme also depends on highly optimistic assumptions about car parking demand. Credible transport studies must be made available.

Housing

The almost complete absence of plans, sections and other information about this major component of the scheme is astonishing, and prevents us adding to the numerous comments we made on the subject in our submission last year. We should point out that compliance with the London Mayoral and Barnet Council housing design standards will be essential, not simply the Nationally Described Space Standards referenced on the exhibition boards.

Trading continuity

The lack of information about phasing of building works and temporary decanting of existing businesses, most of which are essential for the regeneration of the town centre, is worrying.

The Spires developers must up their design game – and drop their building heights

We also have comments on other points:

Permeability

New public pedestrian connections between the development and Bruce Road, and High Street (via the alley between Nos.131 & 133) are desirable.

Mix of uses

We like the idea of a ‘varied offer of retail, F&B, leisure and cultural’ and ‘active community & retail space fronting onto the High Street’ (or is that meant to mean St Albans Road?), but need more detail. ‘Changing places’ and able-bodied public conveniences should also be provided.

Market

We welcome the extra space proposed for the market if demand increases.

Spires Walk

The width between the proposed 5 & 6-storey slabs appears little wider than the smaller of the existing courtyards, and much less than the 21 metres recommended for residential visual and aural privacy. As well as its almost continuous overshadowing (mentioned above), we regret the removal of most of the existing protection from rain.

A further observation: this design would remove the variety and element of surprise that gives the present precinct much of its character. That would be replaced by a long, straight vista focusing the westward gaze on…the anticlimax of the car park entrance. A more inspired townscape gesture is called for.

Green space

The plans indicate plenty of greenery, which would be welcome, but according to the exhibition panels only 80 sq.m. is additional, which seems meagre for a site of this size. Does it include the ‘communal garden’ and its adjacent new greenery? Who would be able to access it, and how would it be kept secure?

Play space

Provision for children’s play is equally ambiguous. We are promised improvement to the green to create a ‘playable’ space. But which green is meant: the new ‘communal garden’ or the Stapylton Road pocket park (which is outside the development site)? And would it be a purpose-designed play area?

Sustainability

The environmental measures offered are heading in right direction, but are ad hoc and unambitious. A project of this size is an opportunity for a more holistic and integrated scheme. Robust assurances on air quality will also be needed, during and after construction.

The Spires developers must up their design game – and drop their building heights

Unless the development team up their design game – and drop their building heights – the impression that they are prioritising residential units and private profit over public benefit will be unavoidable.

Posted on

A never ending challenge: guarding the historic heart and landmarks of Chipping Barnet

A never ending challenge: guarding the historic heart and landmarks of Chipping Barnet

Protecting the historic townscape around Barnet parish church, Hadley Green and Monken Hadley requires the constant monitoring of planning applications – a task that is becoming no easier thanks to cuts made by Barnet Council.

Continue reading A never ending challenge: guarding the historic heart and landmarks of Chipping Barnet

Posted on — 5 Comments

Spires sold to property investor specialising in converting commercial buildings into housing

Spires sold to property investor specialising in converting commercial buildings into housing

A property development company specialising in office-to-residential conversions has bought the Spires shopping centre and its five-acre site between Barnet High Street and Stapylton Road for £28 million.

Continue reading Spires sold to property investor specialising in converting commercial buildings into housing

Posted on — 2 Comments

Medieval banners helping to bring Barnet High Street back to life

Medieval banners helping to bring Barnet High Street back to life

Barnet High Street is once again resplendent with heraldic banners from the Wars of the Roses — just one of the many ways in which the local community will be celebrating this year’s 550th anniversary of the Battle of Barnet.

Continue reading Medieval banners helping to bring Barnet High Street back to life

Posted on — 6 Comments

Barnet Council urged to prepare for possible redevelopment of Spires shopping centre

Barnet Council urged to prepare for possible redevelopment of Spires shopping centre

Critical questions about the future of the town centre will have to be addressed by Barnet Council if plans go ahead to replace much of the Spires with blocks of flats.

Continue reading Barnet Council urged to prepare for possible redevelopment of Spires shopping centre

Posted on — 10 Comments

Hasty removal of historic Barnet sign

Gary Murphy, licensee of the Mitre, and the Historic Barnet sign before it was deemed hazardous for pedestrians

A Barnet Museum information sign that told the history of the coaching taverns that once lined Barnet High Street was removed within days after Barnet Council’s highways department declared it was a hazard for pedestrians.

Continue reading Hasty removal of historic Barnet sign

Posted on — 6 Comments

Plans for attracting High Street shoppers and visitors

Work is underway to widen the High Street pavement between the junctions with Union Street and Salisbury Road

Construction work has started on the pavement build outs in Barnet High Street – an improvement which community groups have campaigned for and which could be backed up by other measures proposed in Barnet Council’s draft growth strategy plan for the borough.

Continue reading Plans for attracting High Street shoppers and visitors

Posted on

Samaritans reaching out to prevent suicidal thoughts

Volunteers John Pyatt and Jacky Bishop ready to help at North London Samaritans’ new call centre

From its new call centre at Bowes Park, volunteers from the North London Samaritans are stepping up their efforts to reach out to help anyone troubled by personal or emotional problems and to advise those most at risk of suicide.

Continue reading Samaritans reaching out to prevent suicidal thoughts

Posted on

Full house at Barnet homeless night shelter

Preparing to serve an evening meal at the night shelter for the homeless at St Mark’s Church, Barnet Vale. From left to right, John Hay, Geoff Nicholson and the Reverend Tristan Chapman

Every Sunday this winter St Mark’s Church, Barnet Vale, becomes a night shelter for the homeless – “our contribution to helping the weakest”, says the Vicar, the Reverend Tristan Chapman.

Continue reading Full house at Barnet homeless night shelter

Posted on — 1 Comment

Campaigning to save traditional public houses

Gary Murphy, landlord of The Mitre, promoting his array of ales and craft beers

Gary Murphy, landlord at one of High Barnet’s highly-rated real ale pubs, the Mitre, is preparing for the next round of an ongoing campaign to force the pub owners to give publicans of tied houses a fairer deal on rents and the price and choice of beers.

Continue reading Campaigning to save traditional public houses

Posted on

Christmas Fayre boosts The Bull pantomime

The official line-up at the opening of Barnet’s Christmas Fayre – Theresa Villiers, MP for Chipping Barnet, the “Lord Mayor of London, Richard Whittington” (David West) and fellow actor, High Barnet Councillor David Longstaff, who is the pantomime dame in Dick Whittington at The Bull Theatre.

Barnet’s annual Christmas fayre broke with tradition this year. Instead of being opened by the Mayor of Barnet, the ceremony was conducted by the “Lord Mayor of London, Councillor Richard Whittington” – star of the Christmas pantomime at the The Bull Theatre.

Continue reading Christmas Fayre boosts The Bull pantomime